Saturday, October 31, 2026

Broadening the Idea of Conflict Sensitivity Prof. John S. Moolakattu

















Broadening the Idea of Conflict sensitivity

 Prof.M. S. John

Greetings to all of you. When I was at Mahatma Gandhi University, Kottayam, I taught a course on Conflict Sensitivity as part of the programme on development studies. We also had a programme on Gandhian studies and development studies, so we examined different forms of sensitivity, such as environmental sensitivity, gender sensitivity, and so on.

When I first tried to teach conflict sensitivity, I found a considerable lack of teaching material, as the field was still in its formative stage. For teaching material, I relied primarily on early contributions from people like Mary Anderson. She wrote a book in 1994, titled "Do No Harm." That became a kind of slogan for people who engaged in post-conflict reconstruction and peacebuilding.


You know, the main issue is preventing conflict and being sensitive to possible conflicts that could emerge because of your intervention, especially as an outsider, whether you are providing a service or supporting certain UN programs. In various ways, each action needs to consider the context in which it takes place. This means understanding how an action and its settings affect each other, and then adjusting so people end up more connected. They don't get divided as a result of your intervention.


This idea has since moved beyond war zones to other areas. Although it initially focused on post-conflict reconstruction, especially after the 90s, it now applies to preventing division in climate projects, various computer applications like WhatsApp and Facebook, markets, and the everyday policymaking governments do—like local, state, and central governments. How do the actions of these governments, agencies, and companies have an impact? Do they divide people, bring people together, or are they blind—neither dividing nor bringing them together? Sometimes,  we use the word "gender-blind" in a similar way.

I'll start with some projects conceived, for example, in India. We have a national climate goal that meets a local livelihood. We have a goal to meet a certain level of energy demand, and we are trying to set up enterprises to produce that much energy. But at the same time, we are oblivious to what is happening in the locale where we intend to install this project. This is a case where we are trying to set up clean power by 2030—500 gigawatts. We aim to achieve this by installing large solar and wind parks in high, open regions.

Now, at Pang, in eastern Ladakh, a park of this kind—with solar as well as wind materials—is being installed. It is about 30 gigawatts on roughly 48,000 acres of the vast grassland. The local herders traditionally used this grassland. They were actually rearing a particular kind of goat known as the Pashmina goat, as well as sheep and yaks. Yaks are quite common in those highlands, including in Tibet. Moreover, these yaks—their fur is used for luxury wool.

Now, the problem isn't that they are against the project; it's that they're afraid because they haven't been consulted. There is no written grazing rights agreement. There's no talk about any compensation framework. The officials say grazing will be protected, and they have begun a grazing-friendly project. In other words, this is a sensitive region—a sensitive border—where many people feel decisions are made elsewhere, far away in Delhi.

Okay, let us not be unfair to anyone. Let's say that there are no villains. The useful question is not who is right, but what happens to trust? Do we trust the authorities who say so? What implications do they have for our livelihoods and our relationships when the project arrives?

So this is something which we need to take into account. This is one scenario. It's like a two-way street—a project and its setting keep acting on each other. We need to understand who the parties are in a conflict situation. We need to know who the parties involved in the conflict are. Who are the key stakeholders? What are the issues? How did this issue actually come into being? We need to know the evolution of this problem's history.

We need to understand how fast this conflict is building, what moderates its escalation, and what could serve as an immediate trigger that accelerates it. To do this, you must review your own resources and engage with them directly. Think about the resources you are going to intervene with: Who are you hiring to serve as project managers and project personnel and where will this project be located? Remember, each stakeholder group will read your message, and the local setting will shape your project in return.


Based on this understanding, you may need to change the design. Sometimes you might make certain adjustments: you may shift the location, reduce the level of investment you intend to make, reduce the quantum of power you intend to generate, or even change the timing. If you intend to start a project immediately, you may instead hold wider consultations and start at a later date.
It is also vital to communicate in a way that weakens what divides people. Communicate upfront, and tell the local community straightforwardly what you intend to do. This brings the community together rather than creating fissures within it. When you hire someone from one particular group, the other group becomes highly suspicious of your intentions. Therefore, clear communication must take place at all stages of the project cycle—from planning and implementation through to evaluation.
Now, mind you, conflict is not the same as violence. Disagreement, of course, is very normal in human affairs. The problem arises when a particular project creates fear in people's minds. They begin to feel that they could be excluded, that their voices may not be heard, and that coercion might be exercised over them with the help of the law enforcement machinery.

 

Of course, the absolute minimum standard is to do no harm. If you cannot do good, at least do no harm. The better standard, however, is to leave people more connected. The better standard is to ensure that, as a result of implementing a particular project or making a certain decision, the people are better off and come together as a group rather than getting divided. It should not lead to what is known as polarisation—and I mean polarisation of the wicked kind. In politics, of course, we expect a reasonable degree of polarisation, which is  a positive force.

Here, I refer to Mary Anderson’s work. She was particularly concerned with aid, though her framework later extended to humanitarian interventions. She found that an intervention affects conflict in two ways: first, through what it brings, in the sense of who gets the benefits of the aid; and second, through the messages it sends regarding who decides about those benefits and who matters in the whole scheme of things.

As you know, communities are very rarely homogeneous. They are divided along ethnic lines, caste groups, class (the rich versus the poor), and between indigenous people and settlers. This brings us to the concept of dividers and connectors. Every action we take actually feeds one or the other.

Dividers push people apart. They lead to unequal access to resources or services, secret or unexplained decisions, a lack of transparency, rumours, and hate speech. For example, during elections in India—a subject I have written a piece on—I actually adapted this framework, changing "do no harm" to "do no polarisation" in the context of Indian election campaigns over the last decade and a half. These dividers, including hate speech, lead to fear among sections of society. They are worsened by a history of prolonged, unaddressed grievances or by separate institutions for separate groups. In other words, dividers push people apart. When people are already divided, a poorly planned project intervention can worsen that division.

In contrast, connectors are those things that bind people together. These include shared markets, festivals, organisations, and spaces. They include respected councils and elders who command respect from all groups, or trusted mediators. Sometimes they need not be so-called neutral mediators. They can belong to a community, but one in which the other group also has faith. People come together on matters like bread-and-butter issues or common needs such as water, roads, and safety. These institutions serve everyone, and people can come together around these issues when projects are designed that way.

Let me bring to your attention  an interesting case. Imagine a village with a tense history between two neighbourhoods that share only one working public tap. Because the tap is in the first neighbourhood, a development group decides to install ten new taps there, simply because a road leads directly into that neighbourhood. Now, the taps themselves are good, but the message it sends to the second neighbourhood is: "You don’t matter. The other side matters more." Consequently, those who are aggrieved will grumble, and this could later escalate into open conflict.

If you are sufficiently sensitive as a planner, you would place those ten taps right at the boundary between the two neighbourhoods, so the other neighbourhood does not feel it is too far away. When you place it at the boundary, they feel it is very close to their place as well. That location creates an opportunity to connect with others, and if a committee from both neighbourhoods runs the system jointly, that setup serves as a vital connector.

Now, looking at the Ladakh case, the problem is that the dividers are rooted in secrecy; things are simply not transparent. People are unsure whether their land rights will be protected. Decisions are not made in consultation with local people; instead, they are made in Delhi or other distant places. On the other hand, strong connectors also exist, such as a shared need for clean energy. The Ladakhi people are particularly well-known for their commitment to environmentally friendly energy. They are far more conscious of environmental issues than the rest of the country because their lives are so intimately linked with nature. Furthermore, they have established local bodies, like the elected Hill Councils. All these existing institutional channels are not being considered. Projects do not merely deliver things; they send messages about who matters. Therefore, conflict sensitivity should not be confined to active war zones alone. Today, it has to travel much further. Whether you are issuing a mining license, updating an online application, or changing a tax policy, you risk opening up structural fault lines and stirring dividers in societies that otherwise look peaceful—even if your intention was simply to profit from the enterprise. This disruption can affect even stable, mature democracies like India, or the United Kingdom, for that matter. Risk builds up most aggressively during periods of rapid change. This happens when a new port comes online, a new platform launches, a sudden price shock hits the market, or a new rule on identity or land rights is introduced. Waiting for physical violence to erupt before you react means you are waiting far too long—violence can surface very quickly.

 

Moreover, any project is embedded in a complex web of laws, markets, platforms and global demand. Decisions made at village, state and national levels constantly interact. In the modern world private companies and digital platforms also shape conflicts. Governments and individual actors do not produce these problems alone. We have to look at the larger system. When structural systems continuously disadvantage the same groups over land, jobs, legal documentation, or political voice, grievances build up silently without requiring a single open act of violence. This is precisely what is known as structural violence: injustice embedded in social and institutional structures. Such violence may not immediately appear in physical form. The aim must therefore move from merely doing no harm towards building positive peace.

Positive peace is fundamentally different from negative peace. Negative peace is simply the absence of physical violence, but positive peace means the actual presence of social justice. Because of this, we need to focus on peace-centred development—development that ultimately leads to sustainable peace. In this framework, peace becomes our superordinate goal.
Let us look at Ladakh, for example. What happened there? A large energy infrastructure project was planned on pastoral commons and announced entirely from the top down.
What was missed? There were no written grazing rights, no open access to information, and no real consultation before they selected the sites.

Consider the Vizhinjam port project in Kerala and the protests around it in 2022. Fishing families, supported by the Latin Catholic Archdiocese of Thiruvananthapuram, protested for more than 100 days over the approximately ₹7,500-crore project. They were deeply concerned about coastal erosion and rehabilitation. They wanted a dispassionate, independent study of the project's pros and cons, rather than government-engineered studies. The state government disputed these claims, and though an expert panel was named in October, the tensions later turned violent.
The core issue was that no evidence anyone could trust was ever gathered. In projects like these, you must seek community consent before sites are fixed. You need to commission rigorous baseline studies to understand the area's current state and project the net results if an intervention takes place. You also have to look at how previous, similar projects have performed. Furthermore, if a project yields benefits, those benefits must be shared with the community

We see similar patterns globally. Take the eastern region of the Democratic Republic of Congo, around Goma. The area is rich in cobalt, and cobalt is in high demand worldwide for batteries as the global market shifts to battery-powered cars and green energy. So, while demand for green energy rises globally, resources are being drained from the Congo, largely because of corruption and weak governance in its eastern parts. The lesson here is clear: we must decide with people, not about them. We must write rights down, and we must agree on the evidence together.
We also see how false messages can trigger severe crises when circulated through apps like WhatsApp and Facebook.

 In July 2018, false warnings about child kidnappers spread in India. Media reports referred to approximately twenty deaths over two months, including the lynching of five men in Dhule, Maharashtra.

Cheap mobile data had reached communities with pre-existing fears and limited trust in official information. Even when the police denied a rumour, past experiences influenced whether people believed them. The forwarding of false information contributed to deadly violence. WhatsApp later restricted forwarding to five chats in India, and extended the restriction internationally in 2019. But these measures came after the deaths.

In Myanmar, a United Nations fact-finding mission and an assessment commissioned by Facebook concluded that the platform had been used to spread hatred against the Rohingya and that the company had not done enough to prevent incitement. This raises the question: what can help in such situations?

Possible measures include forwarding limits, warning labels, fact-checking and moderation in local languages; direct communication with district authorities and community leaders; and digital literacy. Governments must also act carefully. Long internet shutdowns, such as those imposed in Manipur in 2023, can have serious consequences.

An internet shutdown may prevent hate speech or rumours from circulating, but it can also deprive people of vital information needed for safety and survival. Design choices affect how quickly fear travels. Now consider ordinary policy decisions in India.

Assam has long struggled with migration. The 2019 Assam National Register of Citizens, or NRC, left out about 1.9 million of 33 million applicants—roughly 7 to 8 per cent. Under this system, the burden of proof is entirely on the individual to demonstrate their citizenship. If you are poor, that poverty directly undermines your ability to produce documentary evidence. Poverty is not merely the absence of income; it is also an absence of the skills, knowledge, and systemic competence required to navigate complex bureaucratic situations. As a result, the poor, women, displaced individuals, and those affected by natural disasters are terribly disadvantaged when trying to produce identity documents. Assam regularly faces severe floods, and these floods literally wash away homes. When that happens, whatever documents people have left disappear entirely

 

 In 2019, the National Register of Citizens left out around 1.9 million people from approximately 33 million applicants, about 6% of applicants. The exercise placed a burden on people to prove citizenship through documents.

Poverty can affect people's ability to produce documentary evidence. It does not simply mean a lack of income; it can also involve a lack of skills, knowledge or resources to navigate official procedures. Poor people, women, displaced persons and flood-affected families may be particularly disadvantaged. Assam experiences serious flooding, and homes and documents get washed away.

A similar situation was observed in Kerala. About twenty kilometres from where I live, a landslide and severe flooding washed away several houses, especially weakly built homes. Families lost not only property but also essential documents.

When a team of us went there, the first thing we did was advise the community to ask the government to depute an official. This official could directly help them process the documentation needed to secure ration cards and other essential identification cards so they could access vital supplies.

 Now consider Manipur in 2023. A protest march and ethnic violence followed a High Court direction concerning Scheduled Tribe status for the Meitei community.

This resulted in the tragic deaths of nearly 300 people in just a few days. The violence created such deep fractures that the Meitei and Kuki communities now live in strictly segregated, 'no-go' areas where members of one community cannot safely enter the territory of the other. This judicial decision violently stirred long-standing tensions lying just beneath the surface. Although the Supreme Court later intervened, calling it an erroneous decision and striking it down, the harm had already been done. Those making decisions must understand the context, the history and the people likely to be affected.

They must also anticipate possible protests or backlash. In Southport in the United Kingdom, three children were killed in a knife attack in 2024. False online claims about the attacker's identity were followed by riots in several towns, feeding on existing grievances. Decisions involving identity, quotas or land therefore require particularly careful communication.

If an outsider must make an announcement, it may be better to involve a trusted member of the local community in communicating it. Similar lessons emerge from Rwanda, Goma, Lebanon and Mozambique.   

 

In Rwanda, following the genocide, perpetrators gained control of many refugee camps in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Because no security forces were deployed to separate these perpetrators from ordinary refugees, humanitarian agencies faced an impossible dilemma: either provide aid to everyone—including the perpetrators—or withdraw entirely. Organizations like Doctors Without Borders chose to pull out. A joint evaluation in 1996 found that over 200 agencies were operating there in a policy vacuum, without any central coordination. Consequently, a substantial portion of the humanitarian aid was hijacked by the perpetrators, who used it to sustain themselves, purchase weapons, and continue terrorising the population.

 

In Lebanon, aid to Syrian refugees initially overlooked the needs of host communities, leaving many local residents feeling excluded.Tensions arose over jobs, services and the perception that host communities were being neglected.

Similarly, in Mozambique, TotalEnergies commissioned an independent review in December 2022 after staff were forced to evacuate the Afungi peninsula in 2021 due to escalating conflict around its massive gas projects. The common thread across all these failures is that conflict analysis came far too late, project targeting was far too narrow, and no one asked how the surrounding population would perceive the arriving aid or investment.
To prevent this, any intervention in a conflict-prone region must answer four critical questions rooted in the local power dynamic: Who wins? Who loses? Who decides? And who is being left without a seat at the table?

Who is most powerful, who wins, who loses, and who decides? Who is missing from the discussion? What divisions already exist? There may be past disputes over land, water, jobs and trust. Speak with people who have lived in the locality for a long time. Ask how our actions could widen or narrow these divisions, both immediately and in the longer term, at local, state and national levels. Finally, if we are wrong, how will we find out, and what will we change? We need feedback channels.

At every stage, we should reflect on what we have done, taking account of community feedback, grievances, scheduled reviews and the authority to change course. If the people most affected are absent from the decision-making table, we should correct that first. Conflict sensitivity must become more than a project-level tool.

This approach has to widen into a systemic habit in policy and law. When governments introduce bills, issue orders or approve projects, they should consider the potential for conflict. Even budget allocations, which may appear neutral, determine who gets it and who misses out.

Analysis, consultation and adaptation must be incorporated into budgeting and planning.

These are not optional extras. When delivering services, organisations should carefully select and sensitise staff. One major difficulty for international aid agencies is the shortage of personnel with practical conflict-sensitivity skills.

 

Targeting who needs to be focused on, project locations, procurement—from whom should we procure the resources needed to implement this project—and partners: all these decisions should take this into consideration. Will this divide us, or will it unite us? We also need to learn as we progress.

We need to track tension data and set review dates that can change the plan based on the reports we receive. For instance, if there are recent reports of resentment from beneficiaries or something like that, we need to intervene early so it gets corrected.

Accountability is also crucial. Give the affected people grievance channels and allow independent reviews instead of your own organization conducting them. You could create a mixed body of your staff and beneficiaries, or community members involved in the work. So, conflict sensitivity fails when it lives in only one unit, one report, or one project. It has to become a kind of system-wide entity; it has to broaden.

So, governments, policymakers, courts, and commissions—along with the protection of lawful, dissent-based protests—are part of how societies negotiate in a democratic society. Coordinate among levels and ministries. Joint early warning systems involving district officials, police, health and education staff, local bodies, and civil society can sometimes give you signals of one kind or the other. You could take your cue from those signals and intervene early so the project does not lead to divisions and polarisation.

Then, regarding sector policies, I will not get into those details. In each of these sectors, conflict can develop, and sectoral specialists are sometimes not socially sensitive. If I am an economist or a water specialist and so on, we need to spread this message of conflict sensitivity to all these sectoral specialists. These are all sector-related fields: health and education, digital media, migration, identity, citizenship, justice, police, and security. So okay, these are some of the things we already discussed earlier.

I have only a few more points, as I think I have already crossed the time allotted to me. Companies, investors, tech platforms, media, civil society, communities, universities, and think tanks should also play a key role. You should develop conflict-sensitive research ethics, then publish which interventions failed and which worked. That would contribute to knowledge on conflict sensitivity.

There are six conditions. One is the leadership mandate: a senior owner who can actually pause a decision. In other words, a person with sufficient authority who can intervene decisively and maybe correct the course of the project when any particular information is received.

Second are decision triggers: set screening points at the planning stage, budgeting stage, launch stage, and during evaluation. Third is money and time: a budget line. There has to be a budget line; it cannot be volunteer work. Every piece of work must  be monetised. Fourth is skills: practical training for non-specialists—those who are, you know, not sufficiently aware of conflict, conflict sensitivity, conflict analysis, and so on. They should be trained. Fifth is feedback and grievance channels. Finally, tension data must reach decision-makers, followed by review and learning. These things should become part of the system.

At the same time, we need to be aware of a few things. The aim is not to end these projects, stop the investment, or anything like that. We are not abandoning climate action or development, for that matter, but we want to design things much better. And again, not all conflict is bad. Protest is how people negotiate in democracies, so don't dismiss dissent as inconsequential. Instead, you should look at dissent with due seriousness.

And again, you need to be aware of the fact that when you look at a locality, that locality consists of different voices. The "local" is not just one voice speaking for the community. Include women, the marginalised, the youth, and poorer households in decision-making processes. Broadening, of course, can dilute conflict sensitivity. But always keep this in mind: not to divide people, but to unite and connect them. Achieving this connection—human connectivity—is the essence of conflict sensitivity.

Of course, this may sound like a dry subject, but we can practice it in our day-to-day lives. Sometimes people say that using early instruments means you're trying to prevent conflict, which amounts to a kind of conflict avoidance. I must say that there were times when we looked at conflict avoidance as a bad thing. But we know the nature of conflict has changed, and how people view peace varies by locality; there is no uniform way people view peace. So, whatever you can do to prevent violence—even if it results in a negative peace—we should do it. We must try to ensure it happens because lives are otherwise lost, and even if it is a small step, that small step is very crucial.

In our day-to-day lives, for example, if you are a teacher in a school, having a grievance redressal mechanism is a way to preempt conflict. You can see this kind of situation everywhere. So, it is up to you during the discussion to take up any one of these conflicts that I brought to your attention, or you could describe a conflict which you experienced and which could have been prevented if there had been sufficient conflict sensitivity. With this, I will end. Thank you.

Q&A

Question 1- How can we develop conflict sensitivity in classrooms? What methods can be used? Should pedagogy or curricula change?

The typical classroom we are accustomed to is not especially democratic. A few schools have experimented with new teaching methods, but in many classrooms, particularly in India, the teacher controls how knowledge is delivered. It is largely one-sided. Questions may be permitted, but students are expected to stay within certain boundaries rather than fundamentally challenge the teacher.

We need a more participatory environment. The curriculum, too, may sometimes create divisions rather than connections. Students should develop their critical faculties. Paulo Freire's educational ideas are useful here: students should not simply accept what the teacher or curriculum delivers.

They should be able to reflect on what they are taught through their own experience and decide what is reasonable. We must also help children understand the interconnectedness of human and animal life, particularly the unity of human beings. Gandhi emphasized the divine spark within each of us as a source of connectedness. Others may locate that common bond in human rationality.

The idea of oneness should become part of classroom practice. Teachers must be mindful of divisions based on economic circumstances, caste, ethnicity and other factors when choosing class monitors, selecting leaders or assigning tasks.

A conflict-sensitive teacher can cultivate values of connectedness in the classroom.

 

 

 

 

Question No.2: It’s regarding the Vizhinjam port. I believe there are aspects worth considering. Initially, some community members supported the port, but a large agitation arose later. How should we address conflicts when protests are driven by agendas? The port has created employment opportunities.

Similar questions arise with protests around the Kudankulam nuclear power plant in Tamil Nadu. How should governments respond when they believe a large-scale agitation is creating economic, political or religious divisions?

 Answer: The problem was that their demand for an independent fact-finding body was not accepted. If such a body had been established, this conflict might not have arisen in the same way.

It’s commendable that the conflict did not continue for long. Perhaps some of the project's benefits were seen as a form of compensation. Nevertheless, other issues needed to be addressed, including the situation of people affected by earlier coastal erosion and displacement.

Some of those long-standing concerns date back to Cyclone Ockhi. They became entangled with the port dispute, which largely stems from affected people's lack of reliable information.

This information asymmetry can undermine social harmony. Fortunately, the dispute did not escalate further.

 

 











 












 















Salt Satyagraha Campaign Prof. John Chelladurai


 

Gandhi's World View : Strategies Prof. Michael W. Sonnleitner


 

Saturday, October 24, 2026

Principled and Strategic Nonviolence Prof. Prem Anand Mishra


 


Principled and Strategic Nonviolence

Prof. Prem Anand Mishra

I am very happy to see Dr. Siby K. Joseph and Prof. Michael Sonnleitner after a long time in this session. Of course, it is online, but you know, it gives a kind of courage to see the people of nonviolence, whether online or offline. Thank you very much for giving me an opportunity to interact with this edition of the international fellowship course, particularly based on Gandhian nonviolence and peace.

I will speak on what I have understood through different contexts and from people like Ravindra Varma and Narayan Desai. This is not just a theoretical explanation, but a practical understanding of nonviolence in life. Frankly, it is highly challenging to live a nonviolent life in today's context of intense socio-political changes and AI revolutions.

When we talk about nonviolence or we listen about it, there are certain images in our mind. Maybe the images of Mahatma Gandhi, the Dalai Lama, Martin Luther King Jr., and many people around the world. You see that these are the people who are the champions of nonviolence, who try to put nonviolent action into practice. Then, there are certain movements that come to your mind, and you think that this nonviolence is not just a personal virtue, but rather a movement, a campaign. So, let us start with these simple and very ordinary images and our understanding of nonviolence. Two or three principles emerge that can be clearly understood.

First one: nonviolence is a force—an active force. It is very important to understand that this is an active force. Nonviolence is a power. By "power," you understand that you can change or influence other people according to your choice, according to your values. So, it has to be understood as a force. It is not passive. Just because we are not being violent doesn't mean that we are being nonviolent, right? So, we have to understand that nonviolence is an active force, and Gandhi used it extensively in this way.

Secondly—and I think other speakers must have elaborated on this—this is a force that is not just individual. Sometimes it happens that we have charismatic leaders in the world, and we attach nonviolence strictly to them. We think that these are charismatic people, that they are very moral and spiritual people, and this is the reason they practiced nonviolence and lived it as a philosophy. But we have to understand that nonviolence is not something purely individual. If you just think about the work of all these people who come to your mind, you will find that nonviolence is a force that can be organized. It is not an individual virtue; rather, it is very collective. It can be mobilized. A force can be mobilized, whether it is a violent force or a nonviolent force. I am just drawing a parallel here: nonviolence is not an individual thing, but it can be organized. This was the beauty of Gandhi’s campaigns; he showed that nonviolence is a collective force that can be organized systematically for social and political change across the world.

Before we discuss principled and strategic nonviolence, let us reiterate the basic points we must grasp while trying to understand nonviolence. Primarily, nonviolence is an active force; furthermore, it can be organized for social and political change. Please do not be confused and think that just because we are not being violent, it means we are nonviolent. We should not take it for granted. We need to cultivate discipline, and we need to undergo training to be truly nonviolent.

I will share with all of you the findings from a highly significant study published in 2011 by Erica Chenoweth and Maria J. Stephan, titled Why Civil Resistance Works: The Strategic Logic of Nonviolent Conflict (which followed their groundbreaking 2008 journal article on the same topic). In this book, they demonstrate the success rate of nonviolent resistance based on empirical data. They collected data on both nonviolent and violent campaigns, evaluating 323 major conflicts that occurred between 1900 and 2006. Their findings concluded that major nonviolent campaigns achieved a 53% success rate, compared to a 26% success rate for violent campaigns. The success rate of nonviolent resistance based on this empirical study is roughly double that of violent resistance. This study affirms the point we discussed here: that nonviolence is a force that can be organized for social and political change.
Therefore, we do not have to view nonviolence merely as a personal choice. Of course, it is very much personal because it demands individual practice. You also have to keep in mind that it has various dimensions and understandings—it can truly be a way of life. However, we will build our discussion on the premise that nonviolence is an active force that can be organized to achieve structural social and political change.

 

Dr. Siby Joseph has assigned me to discuss with you the theme of principled and strategic nonviolence. Nonviolence is both a profound philosophy and a highly practical technique and method of struggle. I am sure all of you are familiar with the work of Gene Sharp. It is highly likely that nonviolence has already been discussed in this forum primarily as a technique and a method for achieving socio-political change. Indeed, Gene Sharp's 1973 voluminous work, The Politics of Nonviolent Action, stands as a landmark study of nonviolent action across three comprehensive volumes: Power and Struggle, The Methods of Nonviolent Action, and The Dynamics of Nonviolent Action.

However, understanding nonviolence as a philosophy can be quite difficult, particularly for individuals coming from different cultural backgrounds. While I do not want to dive deeply into all of those diverse cultural backgrounds right now, let us look specifically at the Indian or Oriental traditions—the eastern part of our world, including India, China, and Japan.

In the East, understanding nonviolence as a core philosophy is very easy because it is deeply rooted in virtually all of our regional religions. These traditions focus on it intensely. In fact, nonviolence is revered as a cardinal virtue across Jainism, Buddhism, and Hinduism alike. Therefore, in the eastern part of the world, nonviolence as a philosophy and an active way of life is not a challenging concept to grasp; people understand and absorb it quite naturally.

We can even look at the concept of suffering. In the Indian philosophical tradition—across Buddhism and Hinduism—we use the word Tyaga, or sacrifice, to describe this. For many European and Western people, this idea of suffering is something very difficult to comprehend. I am telling you this based on my own experience teaching students in our international course. They often ask, "Why do you think that to be nonviolent we have to suffer? We can dance and still be nonviolent." I always reply, "Yes, of course, that can be true." But at a deeper level, nonviolence is very closely tied to detachment. Philosophically, you are detached, and this represents the very height of Satyagraha, which we will discuss.

So, step by step, we will try to understand the difference between the strategic technique and the philosophy. Gene Sharp listed 198 methods of nonviolent action. It is a wonderful resource, often called the bible of nonviolent action because it is so popular all over the world. People everywhere use these techniques. Even in India, during the Emergency, it was translated right here in Gujarat by Narayan Desai as "Methods of Nonviolent Protest."

Gene Sharp notes that Gandhi was a great person whose true beauty lay in his ability to combine several techniques of nonviolence to suit specific political and social challenges, and then apply them effectively. So, while Gene Sharp still talks about the technique, he acknowledges that this is the principle, but Gandhi possessed a unique quality that allowed him to turn a principle into a functional technique.

I understand that for students, this can be a little confusing. Let us take a very simple example: the sentence "Honesty is the best policy," which we all studied in school. Do you think honesty is a policy, or is it a principle? Is honesty a value, or is it a policy? There are two sides to this.

If you say honesty is merely the best policy, it implies that if you find the policy is no longer working, you can change it and choose to be dishonest instead. But do you really think honesty is just a policy, or is it a value? It is a principle. If it is a principle, then no matter the cost, no matter how much you suffer or how much you lose, you will adhere and cling to that honesty. That is what makes it a value.

This highlights the foundational difference between strategic nonviolence and principled nonviolence. Certain values can be used as a policy. As you know, corporate culture generally adopts these values as a strategy for its own benefit. You will find a lot of discussion around honesty, authenticity, and accuracy. These are all core values, but corporations use them for their own purposes within their business ethics. They talk about ethics, too. However, when we talk about a value in the context of nonviolence, we are not talking about corporate or business ethics. Rather, we are talking about a larger social and political good. A value is always understood within a context, and our context here is entirely focused on the greater social and political good.

This good can be global, national, or regional. It depends entirely on the framework in which you choose to work and discuss it. This is the first point that must be clear. When we talk about the principled tradition, we are treating nonviolence as a core value. Now let us proceed to the core differences between strategic nonviolence and principled nonviolence.

When you say "honesty is the best policy" but actually understand honesty as a value, your primary motivation is moral and ethical. It stems from a deep moral conviction—a spiritual conviction, if you will, though you do not have to worry about the term "spiritual." It is a moral conviction to uphold honesty as a principle. However, when you treat honesty strictly as a policy, your motivation shifts to effectiveness. You choose it simply because it works better than other policies, or because it is less costly.

The exact same logic applies to nonviolence. Nonviolence can be a value for you, or it can be a strategy. When we talk about principled nonviolence, we are talking about a moral and ethical conviction that we cling to, adhere to, and accept until our death. Mahatma Gandhi is a prime example of this. He went so far as to say that he would rather die than see the partition of India. That was his intense moral conviction. He stated very clearly that for him and a few others, nonviolence was a matter of faith and deep conviction; yet he also openly acknowledged that for many of his close associates, it was merely a matter of policy.

So, this distinction is not a new concept that I am introducing to you. Gandhi himself knew that nonviolence was often used simply as a technique. Even during the Indian freedom struggle, Gandhi understood by the time India was approaching independence that most people had used nonviolence as a method rather than as a core value. Had they truly embraced it as a value, the tragic situation that unfolded during the 1947 partition of India would not have occurred.

That is the historical context. What we must understand is that while nonviolence is a moral and ethical conviction, it is also highly effective as a technique because you cannot easily use violence against a state. This is one of the main reasons many people choose nonviolence in protests: they know that violence cannot successfully be inflicted upon the government or massive institutions. The state possesses far more violent power than any population. As Gandhi famously stated, the state is the concentrated and organized form of violence. Therefore, using violence against the state or large institutions is strategically incorrect. This pragmatic view explains why people choose nonviolent action, but it remains strategic; they are using nonviolence as a strategy, not as a value.

Let me give you a very sharp historical example: Gandhi’s Non-Cooperation Movement in 1920. By 1922, the movement was at its peak. However, a very violent incident occurred in a place called Chauri Chaura, where twenty-four policemen were burnt alive. Gandhi immediately withdrew the entire movement. He called it off, and many people criticized him harshly for it. They argued, "We were just about to succeed! We could have overthrown the British power right here in 1922. Why stop the movement now?"

Gandhi replied that the people were not yet ready for true nonviolence. He refused to allow a situation where violence succeeded, because if India achieved power through violent means, a culture of violence would prevail, the nature of power would remain violent, and the nation would be trapped in a vicious circle. He stopped the movement because it was designed to be nonviolent, yet violence had occurred. Even at the height of the campaign, when his own associates criticized him and called him a dictator for withdrawing it, he stood firm. This is the essence of principled nonviolence: even if you are on the verge of success, if violence breaks out, you stop.

If you achieve success through violence, you establish a culture where violence dominates. Today it might be one group using it, tomorrow it will be another, creating an endless vicious circle of violence. How long can that go on? When you treat nonviolence as a value, your goal is to build a society fundamentally rooted in a culture of nonviolence. It is not just about the temporary success of a movement.

Think of the many movements throughout world history. Do you think they really succeeded in their ultimate cause? We often succeed in changing the person in power, but what about the fundamental establishments? What about the core principles upon which the movement was based? We fight for equality, liberty, and fraternity—whether through violent or nonviolent means. But what happens ten years after a movement succeeds? You often find the exact same injustices occurring, and you have to fight all over again. Why? Because we only changed the person; we did not change the system.

Even when we do change the system—and the USSR is a historic example of a systemic change—the core values are often left behind. You can build a system according to structural values, but the value itself must be cherished, replicated, and repeatedly practiced in daily life for it to be preserved and normalized. Unfortunately, this did not happen in the USSR. This is why treating nonviolence as a social value is so vital.

Gandhi tried his absolute best to establish this. His associates, like Vinoba Bhave, carried this forward. Prof. Sonnleitner actually interviewed Vinoba Bhave and wrote extensively about this movement. Vinoba did tremendous work centred around the "change of heart"—changing not just the system, but the people and their core values. However, this is incredibly time-consuming work. It is not like an empirical study where you work for five or ten years, write a good thesis, and then you are done. No, it takes a lifetime of dedication, and very few people in the world are ready to dedicate themselves to that degree. This is why Gandhi insisted that nonviolence is not a temporary stance. You cannot just live a normal life and expect to be nonviolent on a whim; it requires rigorous training.

Therefore, to truly differentiate between the strategic and the principled, we must deeply analyse the relationship between means and ends—the process versus the outcome.

 Philosophically, this relationship between means and ends is highly complicated. To understand it in very easy terms, we must look at the process. We generally fixate only on the outcome. We think about how easily we can achieve a good outcome, and we completely ignore the process. But as Gandhi and the tradition of principled nonviolence argue, there is an intrinsic link—a deeply close relationship—between the process and the outcome. We often separate the two, thinking, "If the goal is good, I will just do whatever it takes to get it." You might get it, but failing to think about the process by which you arrive there causes immense trouble.

Gandhi asserts that the process itself is what matters. The end cannot justify the means. Even if you have a noble end or a larger objective, you cannot pursue that objective through just any means. Your process, your preparation, and your entire approach must be nonviolent; only then will you reach a truly nonviolent outcome.

This can be a little difficult to grasp because there has been a massive historical debate on the means-ends relationship, spanning from Machiavelli in the West to Kautilya in ancient India. There is a prevailing proverb that many political figures treat like a sermon engraved in their hearts: "The ends justify the means." They believe they must become great or powerful, so whatever means they choose to employ are justified. This is the great folly that nonviolent movements expose. In nonviolence, it is the means that matter, alongside the absolute purity of those means.

This truth applies not only to political philosophy but to your personal life as well. If you want to achieve something sustainable—you must look at the process. You cannot win genuine love through foul tricks. There is a highly unbreakable relationship between ends and means or the process and the outcome.

This is not a difficult concept to understand you can experience in practical life. What you have achieved through pure means sustains in the long run. Conversely, whatever unfair means you have used in this life—no matter your age—eventually crumbles, blocks your path, and collapses, forcing you to constantly redefine your position. Principled nonviolence is entirely focused on the means, the medium, the process, and the path by which you move forward.

The third basic difference between principled and strategic nonviolence centres on the concept of conversion, which many people find difficult to understand—particularly those outside the Oriental or Eastern traditions. By "conversion," I do not mean religious conversion; I mean a genuine change of heart. This was one of Gandhi's most vital ideas: changing the heart of the opponent.

 In this process: first you have to change mind of the opponent through negotiation and dialogue, second one is the most crucial element, a change of heart, which; and third, a resultant change of the situation. If you change the mind and the heart of theopposing party, the situation will change naturally.  The whole process relied on love, truth, and suffering.

In strategic nonviolence we follow pragmatic or utilitarian approach focusing primarily on the withdrawing consent. Here the goal is to use nonviolent technique to force coercion, accommodation, or the total disintegration of a massive power structure. Once that happens people feel happy and think the job is done.

However, the major flaw here is that you quickly find yourself trapped in the exact same vicious circle. A coercive power structure exists; you launch a strategic nonviolent movement against it, you succeed, and then you take over that power. What happens next? You end up doing the exact same things the previous rulers were doing. The names may change, but has the actual life of the people or the core cause for which you fought truly been addressed? Unfortunately, it rarely is.

Look at modern democracy. Democracy is a wonderful concept in terms of its institutions and practices. But why are the lives of ordinary people not changing? One party is in power, and the opposition claims, "This is all wrong, we believe in something better, we will fix it." The opposition gets elected to power, and the same patterns repeat. This reveals that the power structure itself is the problem. Whether it is you, me, Michael Sonnleitner, or Siby Joseph who enters that structure, the institutional framework remains.

This is precisely what Gandhi challenged. He did not just seek to replace the British rulers; he tried to establish an entirely new kind of power structure—what he envisioned as a nonviolent state power structure. That framework was not merely about holding political authority; it required a robust value system to develop within the society.

This brings us to the third and final part of our discussion: it is not enough to change the political and power structures alone. Granted, they must be changed because the current system is built upon a violent worldview. In that worldview, a few people will always reside at the privileged centre, while the vast majority remain excluded—either negotiating in the name of democracy or being dominated in the name of the market. Under such a system, exploitation continues unabated.

Today, exploitation is rarely direct; instead, it is imposed upon our democratic lives in the name of "development." Elaborate discourses are constructed to sustain this. Unless you understand the deeper power dynamics at play, you will never see how a positive word like "development" can be weaponized as a tool of exploitation. You must look at it and ask: "Development for whom, and at what cost?" Gandhi challenged this fundamentally.

Beyond changing the power structure, Gandhi insisted that we must actively cultivate a new value system within society. And I will tell you bluntly, with all my academic frustration and understanding, this is the exact reason why principled nonviolence faces such steep resistance. When we talk about changing core personal values, most people simply object because it requires immense sacrifice. By sacrifice, I do not mean that you have to kill yourself. I mean that most of us are simply not ready to step out of our comfortable lives. We refuse to sacrifice our comforts even in our personal lives, which makes changing societal values incredibly difficult.

Principled nonviolence demands that your entire life must have a core purpose and meaning. Gandhi was deeply influenced by Christian principles, in his journey of life. He was born in India, with Hindu and Jain traditions of Gujarat. He went to London, where he encountered Theosophy, studied Christianity, and studied Islam. He then moved to South Africa, where he studied these sacred texts deeply. From these experiences, he developed his profound ideas regarding service and the "love thy neighbour." While these concepts were very much in Hindu, Jain, and Buddhist traditions, it was the Christian concept of seva—of serving one's neighbour—that Gandhi adopted to enrich his value system.

Gandhi was working directly within the Indian context; his philosophical understanding was global in nature.

 

Look at the timeline of his life. From 1888 to 1891, he was in London, and then from 1893 to 1915, he lived and worked in South Africa. These experiences made global person who understood the primary intellectual traditions of his era.

When we talk about Gandhi's entire life's work, we must look at his constructive programme. Through it, he sought to fundamentally transform the social structure—what he envisioned as a clean, decentralized society in India. Yet, we must admit that he did not succeed in presenting a massive, structural challenge to the prevailing capitalist or socialist systems of the world. He envisioned a democratic framework that relied on a highly decentralized mode of governance, but he could not fully implement it.

His own political associates were deeply drawn to the state socialism of the USSR. Consequently, when they assumed power after independence, they opted for what they termed a "mixed economy," combining elements of both capitalism and socialism. As a result, Gandhi’s unique ideas, his philosophy, and his practices were largely left behind—relegated to subjects for us to study, discuss, and draw inspiration from, rather than models put into active practice. This is the exact reason why, although we enjoy many good things today, we are simultaneously confronted by massive structural challenges.

Before we conclude, I want to address a question that many students frequently ask: "Is this really the right time to discuss Gandhi’s philosophy, his value system, and systemic changes? The world has completely changed, and Gandhi's methods were fine for his era, but our modern reality is completely different."

To counter this, I would like to ask: Do you really believe Gandhi’s era was not challenging?

During Gandhi's lifetime, humanity witnessed two catastrophic world wars—from 1914 to 1918, and from 1939 to 1945. Within a span of just fifty years, the world witnessed gross violence and experimentation of weapons of mass destruction. In the middle of that bloodshed and violence Gandhi chose to talk about nonviolence. He spent forty years actively experimenting with nonviolence across South Africa and India.

Frankly, today's world is in a far better state than it was during those two world wars. Remember that his contemporaries included Adolf Hitler in Germany, Benito Mussolini in Italy, and Winston Churchill in Britain.

Therefore, do not mistakenly assume that Gandhi's time was easy and that our current situation is bad or completely devoid of nonviolent possibilities. The possibility for nonviolent change is always present. Even as the world was experimenting with extreme violence and constructing the first nuclear weapons—culminating in the atomic bombing of Hiroshima in Japan—Gandhi stood firm in his conviction.

This brings me to my final closing remark on why Gandhi's principled nonviolence remains absolutely essential for us today. When Hiroshima was bombed questions were asked about the efficacy of nonviolence. Gandhi said “I regard the employment of the atom bomb for the wholesale destruction of men, women and children as the most diabolical use of science.

"What is the antidote? Has it antiquated non-violence?" No. On the contrary, non-violence is the only thing that is now left in the field. It is the only thing that the atom bomb cannot destroy. I did not move a muscle when I first heard that the atom bomb had wiped out Hiroshima. On the contrary, I said to myself, ‘unless now the world adopts non-violence, it will spell certain suicide for mankind.’ “H, 29-9-1946

Today, it must be clear to everyone that humanity will not survive unless we embrace the path of nonviolence. As Gandhi noted, the tragedy of Hiroshima is a powerful illustration of this truth. It serves as an example proving that if humanity is to survive, nonviolence is the only viable alternative to our current power structures and systems.

 

Q&A

1. How do you view the Gen Z protests happening all over the world in today's times from a Gandhian perspective?

That is a very good question. If you look at the Gen Z protests, they are using nonviolence primarily as a technique of mass mobilisation. They are approaching nonviolence strategically.

However, if you measure these protests against true Gandhian parameters, the very first requirement is respect for your opponent. In a Gandhian struggle, even when you oppose people, you must maintain a deep respect for them. You are fighting the evil itself, not the evildoers. When we look at current protests around the world, and particularly in India, we see substantial reasons and valid causes behind them. But if you analyze the methods from a Gandhian framework—knowing the core values that a nonviolent movement ought to possess—you will find that those values are largely absent.

Therefore, I do not see the Gen Z movements as strictly Gandhian. They are nonviolent, mass-mobilized, and highly strategic. In fact, I would clearly say that they represent a very effective, strategic use of nonviolent action—which is far better than turning to violence. But you cannot label them "Gandhian" because Gandhi demanded specific parameters: respect for your opponent's humanity, deep cultural context, concrete historical evidence, a long-term plan, and highly disciplined, trained soldiers. The tactics we see on the posters of the Gen Z movements lack this depth. I deeply appreciate that they remain nonviolent, but from a Gandhian perspective, they require an entirely different kind of orientation.

Facilitator: I am here to remind us of the reality of time. If we want to have our breakout groups, we need to begin quite soon.

Before we split up, I would suggest a synthesis of today’s excellent presentation, if he is willing to endorse this idea. A key element of his argument is that Gandhi actually believed in both principled nonviolence and strategic nonviolence. It is a "both-and" dynamic.

Think about it: if Gandhi had adhered exclusively to a strict definition of principled nonviolence, no real-world strategy would have ever been pure enough for him. He would have remained completely inactive, waiting to achieve a state of flawless, absolute purity before doing anything. Conversely, if he had operated purely on strategic nonviolence—guided solely by a pragmatic desire to win and take over the government—he would have fallen into the trap of coercion. He wouldn't have changed the underlying culture; he would have merely changed the faces in the seats of power.

The current movements use tactics such as fasting to force a change in policy. However, these movements are not truly Gandhian because they do not contain Gandhian principles.

In breakout groups you must discuss this question: Do you agree that a movement must balance both principled and strategic nonviolence? If you agree how can a movement navigate that struggle, in real-world circumstances?

 

Feedback from Groups

 Most of us are back. Let us share a brief summary of what you discussed in your group.

Group One
I will provide a brief summary. In our group, we spoke about fighting the good fight. It is very difficult to have the discipline and training required to practice nonviolence, whether it is used as a strategy or as a principle. Nevertheless, we need to fight the good fight. Another point we discussed was the changing of hearts. As we discussed today, a true change of heart and mind is the only way to achieve something permanent and sustainable.

We then discussed the question of means and ends. If we practice principled nonviolence, it defines who we are. It is not just about a specific situation or scenario; it also depends on us as individuals. We also spoke about how nonviolence is a discourse between two parties, meaning both sides matter during a dialogue or negotiation. It cannot be entirely universal, as we cannot always apply it the exact same way across various contexts.

Group Two
We had a fruitful discussion on today's topic, which is principled versus strategic nonviolence. We focused heavily on the relationship between means and principled nonviolence. One perspective focused deeply on principled nonviolence because their local government is brutal towards them, and they are trying to navigate their struggle through a principled framework.

Another fellow focused on both strategic and principled nonviolence, arguing that both are necessary when using nonviolent paths to achieve a goal. Interestingly, it was also noted that in today's world, it is highly necessary to follow a strategic approach because practicing purely principled nonviolence is quite difficult for us.

Lastly, regarding ends and means, if we want to achieve our goals, we must be mindful of the means we use. If we follow noble means, our results will be more universal and long-lasting.

Group Three
All of us actively discussed both aspects of nonviolence: principled and strategic. However, our primary focus was on the principled nonviolence that Gandhi followed, and we concluded that this approach is deeply needed to bring lasting peace to our troubled world. I must add that while emphasizing principled nonviolence, the participants also highlighted the significance of strategic nonviolence.

Group Four
In our group, we discussed using the idea of principled nonviolence to promote unity and peaceful coexistence across humanity. At the same time, we recognized a need for justice and structural reforms, which may demand the use of strategic nonviolence to achieve a peaceful society. As humans, we come from different backgrounds and hold diverse orientations regarding whether principled or strategic nonviolence is best.

Group Five
We discussed both principled nonviolence and structural nonviolence. Regarding principled nonviolence, we talked about how it must come from the heart and emphasized its importance for the betterment of humanity. We then discussed the importance of structural nonviolence and how it is severely lacking in the current political landscape. Essentially, we discussed the lack of core value systems within political structures and modern democracies, and explored how to address this issue. We concluded that nonviolence is a fundamental value rather than just a technique, and it is something we must actively promote.

Concluding Remarks: As we approach the end of our session, I am confident that many of the important issues raised today will continue to be discussed in our upcoming sessions. Thank you, everyone.

 




COP 31 : A Critical Examination

  About Mr Sagar Dhara Mr. Sagar Dhara is a researcher and writer, with a deep understanding of the energetics (energy flows) of human socie...