Saturday, November 14, 2026

COP 31 : A Critical Examination


 About Mr Sagar Dhara

Mr. Sagar Dhara is a researcher and writer, with a deep understanding of the energetics (energy flows) of human society. Mr Dhara has made significant contributions in various capacities. He has been a faculty member at BITS Pilani, Director (Safety) at Envirotech Consultants Pvt Ltd, and an Environmental Engineering consultant for UNEP.

Mr Dhara has been an active member of several key committees, including the Monitoring Committee of the Male Programme (UNEP), the Supreme Court Committee on Hussain Sagar Lake, the Government of India Task Force on EIA & Environmental Clearance, and various state-level environmental committees in Andhra Pradesh.

Mr. Dhara has worked tirelessly with trade unions, farmers' unions, civil rights groups, adivasi movements, and people's movements for over 40 years, championing environmental justice and sustainability.

Mr. Dhara is affiliated with the South Asian People's Action on Climate Crisis (SAPACC), a coalition striving for sustainable and equitable solutions to climate change.

Mr Dhara holds a BTech in Mechanical Engineering from the prestigious Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay.

Being part of the problem

For all his achievements and scholarship, Mr Dhara is grounded and has a high degree of self-awareness. He (and that applies to all of us, if we pause to think) considers himself to be male, upper class, university educated, city slicker, member of the most ferocious predatory species that ever stalked the earth. That description itself conveys that we are part of the problem: Humans have been exploiting nature for a long time. Only if we realize we are a part of the problem, we will move towards a solution. Otherwise, we will wash our hands off. This realization is indeed critical if we want to deal with climate change.

 Source : https://online.ifheindia.org/An-evening-with-Mr-Sagar-Dhara.html

To see  some of his writings  visit :

https://countercurrents.org/author/sagar-dhara/

 

Friday, November 13, 2026

Fossil Fuels and COP Dr. Michael W Sonnleitner

 

Fossil Fuels and COP 31
Dr. Michael Sonnleitner

I run the risk of trying to cover too much information today. In this topic, I am fairly expert—not because I'm a scientist, but because I'm a political activist. I have been teaching international relations for as long as I've been teaching about Gandhi, for nearly 50 years. Part of international relations, at least during my era of life, has involved climate, climate change, global warming—many concepts that might be confusing to you.

While the focus today is on fossil fuels and COP 31, I found it best, based upon my experience, to assume that at least some of you know almost nothing. I know that in my normal classrooms over the years, that is a normal and good assumption. I want to begin relatively slow and build up. We will get to Turkey. We will get to COP 31. You will know what COP means. We are people from every continent, though I don't know if we have anyone from Australia. We are people of one world.

We don't need to know what the exosphere, thermosphere, and all these spheres are, except that they're all surrounding one sphere, which is oblong and not entirely round. And we call it Earth, Mother Earth, Gaia. It is the planet upon which we live. The planet has layers of atmosphere. The exosphere is up to 1,000 kilometres into outer space, and there are a total of six layers.

Now, rather than get into this in depth, I would like you just to imagine the sun's rays coming into the planet through the atmosphere. That is what warms us. That is what fuels us. That is what gives us life, among other things. There is something called the ozone layer. It's a tiny, thin little layer which is just above the troposphere. The ozone layer is about 12 kilometres—about 5 miles—out from the surface of the planet. We have come to know that the ozone layer is a critical layer that protects us from the ultraviolet rays of the sun.

It's really the UV rays that come in and warm the planet. We need ultraviolet radiation to warm the planet to keep us above freezing. The ozone layer, however, filters this UV radiation. If there was no ozone layer, the UV rays would come in and, yes, warm the planet, but it would also blind all eyes. It would blind us all. From cows and chickens to squirrels to human beings worldwide, we would have no capacity to see.

It would burn all crops if there was no ozone layer. It would fry the planet. The worldwide temperatures might not be too high, but the ultraviolet rays would burn. That's how you or I get a sunburn if you have a lighter complexion. If I'm at a high altitude where I'm closer to the ozone layer, perhaps in a place like Lake Tahoe in the United States, the temperature can be quite cool, but I might burn. My skin would burn. This has happened. I remember it very clearly.

The ozone layer is crucial to life. And we were destroying the ozone layer through producing a chemical called chlorofluorocarbons. We learned in the 1960s that this man-made substance, which was used in air conditioning and aerosol sprays and a variety of really wonderful consumer products, would float up into the ozone layer and create holes. And this was a crisis. We could destroy life on the planet simply by destroying the ozone layer.

Now, I'm not going to dwell on this too far, but I want to start with a note of optimism before we get all depressed, because the world saw—we saw, we weren't blind yet. We saw this danger to the ozone layer, and there met, called by the United Nations, a meeting in Montreal, Canada, in 1987, and the world's nations came together to ban chlorofluorocarbons—the Montreal Protocol of 1987. The world came together, banned the production and use of chlorofluorocarbons, and saw the danger it posed to all of humanity worldwide, all life on the planet.

We created other substances that did not do the same harm for our air conditioning and other purposes. Today, there are virtually no refrigerators in the United States using CFCs, no air conditioners using CFCs, no aerosol spray cans with CFCs—none of this. It has been banned, and the United States has agreed to it, and we are leading the way with other countries to stop this threat to life on the planet. And good news: now, decades after 1987, the ozone layer is healing itself.

The planet is coming back into balance. This is no longer a threat to life. Keep this in mind when we go to Turkey and we see what is happening with climate change there. It can be depressing. But remember Montreal. Remember that it is possible for humanity to wake up and to see the dangers it faces, and to act together as one humankind.

The greenhouse effect takes place when the sun's rays come to the surface of the planet. The ozone is protecting us from UV radiation, but the heat of the sun still gets through. To the extent there is a blanket around the planet, that blanket will keep us warm. We need that blanket. The sun's rays come in, heat the Earth, heat the rocks, heat my skin, and then they bounce off the surface of the planet. Some of that heat goes into space, and some of it is kept by the greenhouse blanket. That is what causes global warming. Remember, we need some warming or we will simply freeze. Rather than fry, which the ozone layer protects us against, we would freeze if there was no blanket.

If the blanket is too thick, then the heat becomes too great. The blanket is caused by various greenhouse gases, including carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide, and methane. We'll get back to that. Most folks focus on carbon dioxide because it is the most plentiful in that blanket. Sulphur dioxide comes from places like coal burning and volcanic eruptions. Methane comes from decomposing matter, from sources like cow manure or decomposing vegetation—which happens when we put in a dam, for example, for hydroelectric plants, flooding an area and creating a large amount of methane. In places like the United States, where we grow a lot of meat, beef, and poultry, the excrement can be in such large supply that it creates a lot of methane. The bottom line is: the thicker the blanket, the more heat is trapped, and the warmer the surface of the planet is. That is what is causing global warming. We need some, but not too much. It's a very fragile balance.

Notice that the sun's rays come in directly toward the equatorial regions, the middle part of the planet, more directly than toward the polar ice caps. The middle of the planet gets warmer, while the polar ice caps, Antarctica and the Arctic, receive more indirect heat. They will get warm, but not as warm. Where the sun's rays hit directly, it's going to be hotter. Where they hit indirectly, more at a slant like at the North Pole, it will warm, but not as much. There is a gap, then, between how much the Earth's surface is heated. The gap is the difference between the equator and the Arctic.

Now, some of my students get confused. They say, "Well, I can understand global warming, but what's climate change?" Climate change is a result of the greenhouse effect and the sun's rays hitting at different angles in different parts of the planet. There may be a hot air mass around Mexico, and a much colder air mass up in northern Canada. It's still warmer than it would have been, but it's colder. The gap between Mexico and the north of Canada is great. The greater the gap, the greater the storms. The colliding of the cold and hot air masses creates turbulence.

The greater the gap, the greater the hurricanes, the greater the tornadoes, and the greater the strength of typhoons in the South Pacific. It seems a little strange that global warming would have different climate effects in different parts of the world. In North Africa, it will expand the Sahara Desert. And yet in places like Oregon, where I live—which is a mid-latitude, almost midway between the equator and the North Pole—it will result in greater rainfall and flooding. So, it affects weather patterns worldwide in different ways.

The overall average heat of the planet may increase, but with dramatically different impacts on the surface of the planet depending upon whether you are close to the equator or closer to the North Pole. The greenhouse effect causes climate change. Donald Trump observes this and says, "You say it's getting warmer. I say it's a hoax because we're having colder winters in some parts of Canada. So global warming makes no sense. It's getting colder in some places." Trump can't grasp this impact of global warming upon climate change. I'm hoping you can, and I'm hoping I haven't confused you.

From Mr. Trump's perspective, it's all a hoax, a myth. That's why he took the United States out of what he calls "the scam that was the Paris Climate Accords." His perspective is: "We want to have industrial development. We want to bring manufacturing back to the US. We want to drill, baby, drill more oil. We want to burn, baby, burn, create more jobs. Climate change and global warming is a myth. It's a hoax. It's fake news." You can see how people who cannot grasp the difference between global warming and climate change get very confused. And that's the best I can say of Mr. Trump: he's very confused, and it has a horrible impact upon many people throughout the world.

Now, let us turn to the Earth's six major mass extinctions. We're going to get a little bit more depressed; I'll just warn you. But this is nature. Before human beings were around, we were having this issue. Species became extinct, and new species came into being. This is nature's way of simply evolving.

Many, many millions of years ago, the Earth did largely freeze over, and 85% of the species at that time died. A second mass extinction took place with 75% of species becoming extinct. A third, during the Triassic period, saw 95% of species become extinct. Each had different causes—extreme cold was the first cause.

Changes in the acidity of the oceans, where most life lived, was the second cause. A third cause involved the changing of the continents moving. We once were all together as Pangaea, as you may know, and gradually over time the continents moved to where they are now, which appear to be very far apart, though once we were all together.

The Jurassic period extinction was caused by volcanic eruptions, releasing a lot of sulphur dioxide particularly into the atmosphere, causing dramatic increases in the greenhouse effect and global warming that killed many, many species. The fifth great extinction was, by all accounts, caused by a meteorite that hit the Yucatan Peninsula near Mexico. It caused a massive cloud of debris that went worldwide and seriously cooled temperatures because the debris in the atmosphere prevented the UV radiation from warming the planet. Effectively, 75% of life as we then knew it died.

Now we're in the sixth extinction. We're in it. It's happening now. The sixth extinction, by all accounts, is primarily human-caused. It's industrial society, a dramatic increase in population, destruction of habitat, and increased carbon, sulphur dioxide, and methane in the atmosphere creating greater heat. This is causing many fragile species to become extinct. This began perhaps 50 years ago and is ongoing.

To give you an idea of the current extinction, we can look at a few facts that are sobering. As of 1975, about 50 years ago, there were 16 million plant, insect, and animal species known to exist on Earth. There may be more, but there were 16 million in 1975. Today, there are 8 million. Already, we've had a mass extinction involving 50% of the species of life on the planet. And this coincides with a dramatic increase in carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases affecting the warmth of the planet and creating climate change.

We're down to 8 million species. COP 17, which relates to the biodiversity convention, met recently in September for its 17th year, and they are predicting that we will have 1 million more species dead by 2050, and 2 million more extinct by 2100. And who knows how much more severe the extinction will be? It depends largely upon us. We're creating this mass extinction by the way we live. We're reaping what we sow. It is karma.

It is part of our industrial way of life, if you want to call it that. Gandhi would say, "Industrialize and perish." He didn't know about global warming and climate change, but he knew about perishing. He knew that we would reap what we might sow. From 1975 to now, we have killed half the species on Earth, and we're continuing to escalate. That is the climate emergency. That is what people like Greta Thunberg describe as the climate emergency.

She is one of my favourite climate activists. She's now 23 years old. At a young age in Sweden, she began a one-person movement outside the parliament, aware of global warming and its impact upon this mass extinction. She went every day after school to plead for the lawmakers to act. Today, she's known worldwide. She has been nominated for several Nobel Peace Prizes, though she's too radical to win any of them. She is, to me, an inspiration. Take note of her name, Greta Thunberg, and find out about her on your own.

She has inspired young activists worldwide to express themselves. And I might add that she has what we might call a disability, though it's a strength: Greta Thunberg has autism. She is brilliant of mind, though in her case, she is not very socially aware. She has a hard time communicating with people. She doesn't always see their body language. She doesn't always understand their emotions.

She is like a logic machine. She is brilliant. She sees what is the truth, and she holds firm to the truth. Does she sound Gandhian? Yes. She holds firm to the truth as she sees it: "We're killing the planet. We're killing the planet." She doesn't care what people think about her because her autism prevents her from really processing what other people might be thinking about her. She doesn't get their emotions. She's immune from criticism. She simply speaks what she believes to be right.

And she is at COP 31 in Turkey now, for the first time in five years. The last Conference of the Parties that she attended, she made headlines because, as a teenager, she looked at the deliberations and was asked, "Well, what do you think about this, Greta? What do you think about these world leaders coming together from 190 countries of the world—these 50 and 60,000 people coming together to express their concern about climate change? Greta, what do you think about it?" Her response was: "Blah, blah, blah."

We're going towards a mass extinction which affects our own food supplies. It's not just about the monkeys and the fish. It's about us not having enough food in the future to sustain us. These people are captured by the oil interests, by the fossil fuel industry. They're meeting together for show. They're telling us how much they care, and they are not doing anything. Blah, blah, blah."

When I heard that, I thought, she's speaking the truth. "Blah, blah, blah" is mostly what we're talking about. The UN conventions create all sorts of wonderful frameworks. They can see the danger, but they're not really creating any enforceable policies to act against the dangers. "Blah, blah, blah" is a great summary. We must go beyond "blah, blah, blah" to action.

Now, let us understand what COP is, focusing on fossil fuels and COP 31. COP 31 is happening now. What is COP? There are many COPs—that's confusing—and many of them are interrelated, though they meet in separate conferences. They all serve as the supreme governing and decision-making body of the conventions or treaties that they are seeking to enforce. A Conference of the Parties simply means a conference of those countries who are signatories of the conventions and treaties that they're trying to enforce. They're parties to the treaties.

In this case, COP 31, which is meeting in Turkey in the city of Antalya, is the 31st annual meeting or conference of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, the UNFCCC. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change was created 31 years ago—that is why this is COP 31. It's the 31st annual global convention seeking to increase enforcement of what? The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change includes both the Kyoto Protocol and the Paris Accords.

Briefly, the Kyoto Protocol of 1997—created 10 years after the Montreal Convention helped resolve the ozone depletion problem—set binding targets for 37 industrialized countries to reduce greenhouse gas emissions—that's carbon dioxide, sulphur dioxide, and methane—by 2012 to an average of 5% below 1990 levels. Kyoto was signed in 1998, but didn't come into force until 2005, nearly a decade later, when Russia signed. You can see that these treaties are negotiated, they're signed, and typically they don't come into effect until enough countries ratify them. So, there's already a massive lag on coming to an agreement and then actually trying to enforce it. It sounds like "blah, blah, blah" to the people who want action.

The Paris Accords were from 2015. They replaced the Kyoto Protocol, and they entered into force in 2016. 195 countries signed, agreeing to set their own voluntary emission reduction targets. These are known as NDCs—Nationally Determined Contributions. And already you can hear what Greta is saying. You can hear what she is thinking: "Voluntary. We have voluntary greenhouse emission reduction targets. Wonderful. 195 countries are going to voluntarily reduce carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. Wonderful. And they're going to submit new plans every five years. And they're going to report on their progress. Wonderful." You can hear her sarcasm. In a sense, it is wonderful that we can come to those agreements. But to people like Greta, it's just more "blah, blah, blah." We need action. We're facing a species extinction event. We're in it. We can't just talk about it unless we want it to go on and grow deeper and worse.

What is the aim of Paris Accords? The accords sought to create a climate-neutral world by 2050, limiting global warming to below 2 degrees Celsius, and preferably 1.5 degrees Celsius. Currently in 2026, 11 years after the Paris Accords, the globe is at 1.5 degrees. We have reached the limit of global temperature increase that Paris was designed to prevent us from reaching. And we're looking, by all accounts, at going beyond 1.5 degrees. We will probably go beyond 2 degrees, and we can see the impact: again, species extinction. Let's not forget it.

According to Greta, myself, and many others, this is a climate emergency, and we're not acting as if it's an emergency. "Our house is on fire," Greta Thunberg would say. And yet, we're still in the house. We haven't even gotten outside the house yet. It's burning. And yet, we're meeting in Turkey. Delegations from over 190 countries are there. They reached their destination using 90 chartered jets, bringing delegations in private, chartered jets—again adding to global warming through the burning of fossil fuels just to get there. And Greta's saying, "Blah, blah, blah." She's there this time, and she's going to be a very vocal part of the discussions. She's not a delegate; she's a protester.

When we look back at the history of our planet, we are reminded of past mass extinctions and the fragility of our environment. Looking at annual carbon dioxide emissions—just one of the greenhouse gases produced by burning fossil fuels like oil and natural gas—the trajectory is alarming. In 1900, global output stood at two billion tons of CO₂. Back then, the world was in the Industrial Age, though not yet heavily into it.

By 2023, however, emissions had climbed precipitously, turning the amount of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere into a mountain. Today, China is the number one emitter, producing more carbon dioxide than any other country on the planet. The United States held that top spot for a long time before China overtook it. Currently, federal leadership under Mr. Trump is pushing policies that risk putting the U.S. back in that position, as the nation is failing to curb its carbon dioxide emissions effectively.

Meanwhile, India contributes 8.1% of global greenhouse gases, and that share is increasing dramatically. The rest of Asia, from Vietnam to Japan, accounts for 12.6%, the Middle East stands at 8.3%, and Russia is at 3.0%. Europe accounts for 8.4%, and after growing dramatically in the past, its emissions are now actively decreasing. Europe—and especially Germany—is significantly reducing its carbon dioxide output. They signed the Paris Climate Accords, set strict emission standards, and are meeting their goals.

This success comes down to strong public awareness and a powerful green movement. The Green Party in Germany is the strongest of its kind in the world; even with around 10% of the vote, they remain extremely prominent as both protesters and policymakers. As a result, Germany is leading the way in renewable energy. China is also leading in renewable deployment, even while remaining the top carbon emitter. In the United States, emissions have largely stabilized, though this is no thanks to federal policy. Instead, it is driven by local action—led by figures like Governor Newsom of California, the nation's largest state with 40 million people—alongside many other cities and states working independently to cut carbon emissions.

Looking at the broader picture of global carbon emissions, output rose by 1% between 2021 and 2022 alone and continues to project upward. While the United States remains mostly stable and the European Union is in decline, China's dramatic surge has made it the top emitter, and India is rising rapidly. Between 1960 and 2020, India increased its carbon emissions by 6%, expanding its share of the greenhouse blanket at a faster rate than even China. While India's overall total is still lower than that of China or the U.S., its percentage growth outpaces the rest of the world. In an effort to catch up with China's GDP, India is burning oil, natural gas, and coal as quickly as possible—a path that harms the global climate and runs counter to the values of figures like Gandhi.

Sulphur dioxide, on the other hand, offers somewhat of a success story. Primarily caused by burning coal, global sulphur dioxide emissions are steadily declining as the world reduces its reliance on this dirty fuel. International efforts, such as the annual UN Conferences of the Parties, are making a measurable difference. However, regional exceptions remain a serious concern: sulphur dioxide emissions are still rising dramatically in the Middle East and increasing significantly in India, showing that key areas are still not conforming to the global downward trend.

Methane, or CH₄, presents another major challenge. It stems from wastewater, landfills, livestock excrement, and rice cultivation, particularly as the chaff decomposes after harvest. Currently, methane emissions are increasing in Russia, China, India, the United States, and Brazil. This is critical because methane is 10 times more potent than carbon dioxide per unit, making it one of the most severe drivers of greenhouse warming.

Ultimately, our industrialized rush to development is still overwhelmingly powered by fossil fuels: 28% coal, 34% oil, and 25% natural gas. By comparison, hydroelectric power accounts for just 3%, nuclear power for 5%, and other renewables—including solar, wind, and geothermal—make up only 6%. While renewable energy is growing, overall consumption remains dominated by fossil fuels, and the global transition is happening far too slowly to satisfy climate advocates like Greta Thunberg. Across the entire global energy supply, renewables account for just 5.6%. Finally, it is worth taking a brief moment to examine the drawbacks of nuclear and hydropower—because while nuclear energy is clean when compared to fossil fuels.

"Looking at the questions Michael raised, I think Greta Thunberg would definitely call the COP 31 '3535' goal 'blah, blah, blah.' Reaching 35 percent electricity production by 2035 sounds nice on paper, but if that electricity is still coming from coal, oil, or nuclear plants, it completely misses the point. Real climate action isn't just about switching to electric grids—it's about how we generate that power and who controls it.

When we look at the data—like the last few years shattering global heat records—it's clear we are in a climate emergency. Yet, globally and locally, we aren't acting like it. In wealthier nations, our policies are still built around protecting high-consumption lifestyles rather than making systemic changes. Meanwhile, the people who contribute the least to the problem, like communities in the Global South or those displaced by massive dam projects, pay the highest price.

Neither Greta Thunberg nor Mahatma Gandhi would be pleased with where we are. Greta has repeatedly called out world leaders for offering vague future promises instead of immediate fossil fuel phase-outs. And Gandhi, who championed local self-reliance and simple living, would strongly oppose centralized megaprojects that harm ecosystems and marginalize the poor.

If we actually want to treat this like an emergency, we need to shift government subsidies away from fossil fuels and nuclear energy, and put them directly into decentralized, community-owned solar and wind power—while seriously rethinking our own consumption habits."


Feedback from Group Discussion

Moderator: Most of us are back. We would love to hear from the groups about what happened in your discussions through your feedback.

Group One: I think the answer to the main question is no—they do not have sufficient ambition to avoid "blah, blah, blah." What our group brings to the table is that we need to focus on the individual level, the government level, and all other layers to ensure things happen, and if they don't, we need to take action. I think that is the brief summary of my group. Well, in addition, we concluded that there is not enough sensitization, education, and self-awareness for people to act. And even where there is, there is this nonchalant attitude among all of us. So, there is no sufficient ambition—it is only "blah, blah, blah," and that is all.

Group Two: We paid more attention to the idea that at the individual level, every person should put effort into addressing climate change, and the government should also put effort into driving climate solutions.

Group Three: We also discussed developed versus developing countries, and how the same rules cannot apply to both because conditions are different. I heard in one speech External Affairs Minister of India  saying that we are trying to take care of 1.6 billion people. That is a very tall order, and developing nations have to pursue whatever means they can to lift people above the poverty line. We cannot expect the same rules to apply to them as to the US or Canada.

The discussion focussed on how to keep progressing forward as much as possible. Because of internal population shifts—where people move from one place to another due to floods or other disasters—that also affects climate change. There are so many variables, and the solutions are going to be different in each situation. I want to add one more thing: I felt that it is not right to have voluntary compliance. Countries should get together and set mandatory targets, otherwise nobody is going to follow through, and there should be consequences for failing to meet them. Thank you.

Group Four: We discussed that first, from Gandhi's perspective, whatever we are doing for climate change or energy should reach the last person in the country—the lowest economic category. The challenges we discussed include supply chain issues in managing energy, greed, and financing. Second are government policies; for example, in India, there is suddenly a cap on subsidies, and now the government says they will only take energy generated during the daytime, with a cap on the units they will reimburse. So, the government is not clear and changes policies frequently. Meanwhile, in countries like Syria, due to war, there is fuel and electricity scarcity. Everyone is putting solar on their buildings and using solar energy, but again, there are financing issues—not all individuals can afford it. Finally, there is a political angle where some developed countries dominate developing countries and exploit them regarding energy, and as Greta mentioned, there is a capitalist lobby influencing all these fuel and energy decisions. So those are the points we discussed. Thank you.

Concluding Remarks: Of course, mandatory targets are a good idea, but they tend to be difficult in an international system that has no enforcement capacity. We make a rule—say, against war crimes or genocide—and there is no consequence. We will, of course, be discussing Israel and Palestine next week.

Basically, despite the fact that we have different realities in different parts of the world, we are still one ecosystem. What affects one directly affects all indirectly. Martin Luther King Jr. was right: if the United States continues to produce greenhouse gases, it creates climate change in Africa. Everyone contributes to everyone else's reality. Inspired by Gandhi, I think it is important for us to realize that yes, we need to live by personal example, my family needs to live by example, my village needs to live by example, and my region needs to live by example. We are returning to Swadeshi, right?

Decentralized energy production is much more likely to be controlled by the people rather than large corporations. Consider the difference between generating wind power through a small windmill on your farm versus massive turbines spread over acres of land owned by a large electricity company. There is a big difference. Gandhi would suggest: think locally, build locally, act globally—decentralize, decentralize. This is anti-corporate.

I am trying to get my state of Oregon to agree not only to provide energy production systems at a low or subsidized cost for every small business and home in the state, but also to connect them all to the electricity grid. If I produce more electricity at home than I need, I can be paid for it. In other words, we decentralize production so it is not controlled by large corporations. This is not impossible; it is a matter of will. In Africa, we have the technology, though not so much the financial resources yet.

There needs to be capital provided by COP 31 and other major conferences to redistribute the means by which we improve our lives from wealthy countries to poorer countries. There needs to be a transfer of the means to produce electricity and stability for our common good. It is in the self-interest of wealthy countries to help poorer nations avoid burning coal and fossil fuels, which increases global warming and affects everyone, including the wealthy countries. We must help one another.

Gandhi is relevant—can you see it? Swadeshi and Swaraj are extremely relevant, and a global green movement—not necessarily a political party, but a movement—is necessary to preserve what we can from this sixth global extinction. We need to act now. That is a sober tune, but we can do it. I hope that you can be inspired by Greta and others to see that change is possible locally and globally.

 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Sustainability and Sustainable Development Dr. Sby K. Joseph

                          

Understanding Sustainability and Sustainable Development

Dr. Siby K. Joseph
Director, International Online Fellowship Program on Nonviolence and Peace (IFPNP)
Sevagram Ashram Pratishthan, Wardha, Maharashtra, India


1. Introduction:

While addressing the fellows of the IFPNP last year, I stated that "sustainability" has become an overused cliché, causing confusion about what it stands for. I also referred to Michael D. Lemonick’s (former editor at Scientific American and Time) article, "Top 10 Myths About Sustainability," published in Scientific American Special Editions Vol. 19, No. 1s (March 2009).

These ten myths reveal that sustainability is not merely about the environment, nor is it a synonym for "green" or recycling. Achieving it does not mean lowering our standard of living, nor can it be accomplished solely through consumer choices, grassroots activism, population limits, or technology.

He concludes that: “You cannot really declare any practice 'sustainable' until you have done a complete life-cycle analysis of its environmental costs. Even then, technology and public policy keep evolving, and that evolution can lead to unforeseen and unintended consequences. The admirable goal of living sustainably requires plenty of thought on an ongoing basis.”

Even though he calls these statements myths, they highlight real-world concerns. Ultimately, these myths serve as a diagnostic map, showing exactly where society experiences confusion, vulnerability, and friction in the transition to a sustainable future.

If you refer to the meaning of the term "sustainability," you can see that it refers to something that lasts for a longer period of time. For example, according to the Cambridge Dictionary, sustainability means "the quality of being able to continue over a period of time." In relation to the environment, it states that it is "the quality of causing little or no damage to the environment and therefore able to continue for a long time." Linking it further with natural resources, the Cambridge Business English Dictionary defines it as "the idea that goods and services should be produced in ways that do not use resources that cannot be replaced and that do not damage the environment," as well as "the ability to continue at a particular level for a period of time."

The term development is closely linked to the question of sustainability. Therefore, I will use the same keywords for our discussion on sustainable development:

  1. Development
  2. Progress
  3. Growth
  4. Sustainability
  5. Evolution
  6. Balancing

Here also, I use the process of evolution to understand what sustainability and sustainable development mean. Bringing sustainability into the discourse was the result of crises and a continuum of development concepts and frameworks that emerged from time to time. When we trace the thread of evolution across different stages of the concept of development, we begin with the Second World War and move toward the era of Late 1980s–2015: Development as Sustainability.

As we are discussing this theme independently, I think we should start our analysis from that same foundational framework—1940s–1960s: Development as Growth—because this model caused severe damage to the environment, and the modern discourse on sustainability can be traced soon after that.


2. Preparing the Ground: The Club of Rome (1968) and The Limits to Growth (1972)

The formation of the Club of Rome in 1968 was a major landmark that contributed toward evolving discussions on the sustainability of the present model of development. The mission of the Club is to promote an understanding of the global challenges facing humanity and to propose solutions through scientific analysis, communication, and advocacy. The Club of Rome believed that the theory of continuous growth propagated by mainstream economists would ultimately result in a planetary collapse. Thus, they decided to focus on the theme "The Predicament of Mankind" in June 1970.

In 1970, the Club of Rome commissioned an international team of researchers at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) to study the implications of continued worldwide growth. They examined the five basic factors that ultimately limit growth on this planet: population increase, agricultural production, non-renewable resource depletion, industrial output, and pollution. This research resulted in the publication of The Limits to Growth (1972).

The message of the book also offers a note of hope:

  1. If the present growth trends in world population, industrialization, pollution, food production, and resource depletion continue unchanged, the limits to growth on this planet will be reached sometime within the next one hundred years. The most probable result will be a rather sudden and uncontrollable decline in both population and industrial capacity.
  2. It is possible to alter these growth trends and to establish a condition of ecological and economic stability that is sustainable far into the future. The state of global equilibrium could be designed so that the basic material needs of each person on earth are satisfied and each person has an equal opportunity to realize his individual human potential.

These conclusions directly dismantled the post-war assumption of infinite economic expansion (such as Rostow’s stages of growth) and introduced the concept of planetary carrying capacity, proving that exponential consumption on a finite planet leads to systemic collapse rather than endless prosperity. It actually served as the intellectual blueprint for sustainable development. It should be noted that the authors used the word "sustainable" fifteen years before the 1987 Brundtland Report popularized it.


3. UN Environment Programme (UNEP) – 1972

The Limits to Growth brought into the limelight the impact of the foundational framework—1940s–1960s: Development as Growth—that we discussed in the last session. As a result, from the 1970s onwards, environmental issues were added for the first time to the roster of international concerns, which resulted in the organization of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment (also known as the Stockholm Conference).

It was an international conference convened under United Nations auspices, held in Stockholm, Sweden, from June 5–16, 1972. It marked a turning point in the development of international environmental politics. This conference adopted a declaration of principles and an action plan to fight pollution. The first principle asserts that: “Man has the fundamental right to freedom, equality and adequate conditions of life, in an environment of a quality that permits a life of dignity and well-being, and he bears a solemn responsibility to protect and improve the environment for present and future generations.” It was to further the goals of this major international conference that the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) was founded.


4. The Brundtland Commission and Our Common Future (1987)

Building on the momentum generated by the Stockholm Conference, the international community sought a comprehensive long-term framework to reconcile economic aspirations with ecological limits. Following a General Assembly resolution in December 1983, Javier Pérez de Cuéllar, the then Secretary-General of the United Nations, asked the former Prime Minister of Norway, Gro Harlem Brundtland, to create an organization independent of the UN to focus on environmental and developmental problems and solutions.

The 1983 General Assembly of the United Nations established the Commission with Resolution 38/161, "Process of preparation of the Environmental Perspective to the Year 2000 and Beyond." In A/RES/38/161, the General Assembly suggested that the Special Commission, when established, should focus mainly on the following terms of reference for its work:

  • (a) To propose long-term environmental strategies for achieving sustainable development to the year 2000 and beyond;
  • (b) To recommend ways in which concern for the environment may be translated into greater co-operation among developing countries and between countries at different stages of economic and social development and lead to the achievement of common and mutually supportive objectives which take account of the interrelationships between people, resources, environment, and development;
  • (c) To consider ways and means by which the international community can deal more effectively with environmental concerns, in the light of the other recommendations in its report;
  • (d) To help to define shared perceptions of long-term environmental issues and of the appropriate efforts needed to deal successfully with the problems of protecting and enhancing the environment, a long-term agenda for action during the coming decades, and aspirational goals for the world community, taking into account the relevant resolutions of the session of a special character of the Governing Council in 1982.

As per the UN resolution of 1983, the World Commission on Environment and Development (WCED) was established, and it published a report entitled United Nations Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development: Our Common Future in 1987. The document also came to be known as the Brundtland Report after the Commission's chairwoman, Gro Harlem Brundtland.

This report provided the guiding principles for sustainability and sustainable development as we generally understand the term or the concept in modern parlance. The Report pinpointed that global environmental challenges were primarily the result of the enormous poverty of the South and the non-sustainable patterns of consumption and production in the North. It called for a policy prescription that clubbed development and the environment together and coined a new term called sustainable development. The terms sustainability and sustainable development became popular in the discourses of development with the publication of this report. It underlined the need for sustainable and enduring development. The Report inter alia stated:

“No single blueprint of sustainability will be found, as economic and social systems and ecological conditions differ widely among countries. Each nation will have to work out its own concrete policy implications. Yet irrespective of these differences, sustainable development should be seen as a global objective.”

The report defined the concept of sustainable development in the following words:

“Humanity has the ability to make development sustainable to ensure that it meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs. The concept of sustainable development does imply limits — not absolute limits but limitations imposed by the present state of technology and social organization on environmental resources and by the ability of the biosphere to absorb the effects of human activities. But technology and social organization can be both managed and improved to make way for a new era of economic growth. ..., but sustainable development requires meeting the basic needs of all and extending to all the opportunity to fulfil their aspirations for a better life ... Sustainable global development requires that those who are more affluent adopt lifestyles within the planet’s ecological means - in their use of energy, for example. Further, rapidly growing populations can increase the pressure on resources and slow any rise in living standards; thus sustainable development can only be pursued if population size and growth are in harmony with the changing productive potential of the ecosystem. .. sustainable development is not a fixed state of harmony, but rather a process of change in which the exploitation of resources, the direction of investments, the orientation of technological development, and institutional change are made consistent with future as well as present needs.”

The Report widened the very notion of sustainability:

“Sustainability requires views of human needs and well-being that incorporate such non-economic variables as education and health enjoyed for their own sake, clean air and water, and the protection of natural beauty. It must also work to remove disabilities from disadvantaged groups, many of whom live in ecologically vulnerable areas, such as many tribal groups in forests, desert nomads, groups in remote hill areas, and indigenous peoples of the Americas and Australasia.”

These ideas were adequately represented in defining what sustainability is. In the Charter for the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) Sustainability Committee, sustainability is defined as:

“the integration of environmental health, social equity and economic vitality in order to create thriving, healthy, diverse and resilient communities for this generation and generations to come. The practice of sustainability recognizes how these issues are interconnected and requires a systems approach and an acknowledgement of complexity.”

Critical Perspectives on the Brundtland Framework

Though the report seeks to reform the pattern of development, the changes it suggested were not fundamental or drastic in their very nature. That is why Amartya Sen wrote:

“I argue that this way of understanding sustainability, while a great improvement, is still incomplete. There are important grounds for favouring a freedom-oriented view, focusing on crucial freedoms that people have reason to value. Human freedoms include the fulfilment of needs, but also the liberty to define and pursue our own goals, objectives and commitments, no matter how they link with our own particular needs. Human beings are reflective creatures and are able to reason about and decide what they would like to happen, rather than being compellingly led by their own needs—biological or social. A fuller concept of sustainability has to aim at sustaining human freedoms, rather than only at our ability to fulfil our felt needs.”

Similarly, Ben Purvis, Yong Mao, and Darren Robinson, while analysing the three pillars of sustainability, raise a pertinent question:

“‘Sustainability’ and ‘sustainable development’, … are often so intertwined in the literature that they remain difficult to tease apart. It is through this conflation though that economic growth-centred ‘development’ becomes an implicit part of ‘sustainability’, skipping over the questions: Development of what? Development for whom? Such strategic ambiguity allows this fuzzy concept to be utilised by any actor for their own means.”

In August 2026, I had the opportunity to participate in the National Seminar on “Intellectual Dialogue between Tradition and Modernity: Synthesis, Challenges, and New Possibilities,” organized by the Faculty of Humanities and Liberal Arts, Scope Global Skills University, Bhopal. The theme of my address was Sustainability, Gandhi, and Traditional Ecological Knowledge.

While analysing the Brundtland Report, I described it as an assertion of the myth of growth-driven sustainability. First, it claims that “technology and social organization can be both managed and improved to make way for a new era of economic growth.” In my analysis:

“This statement is inherently contradictory; this proposed ‘new era’ relies entirely on unlimited material consumption—the core tenet of modern industrial development. Rather than challenging the status quo, it seeks to rescue global capitalism through clever technological engineering.”

Secondly, the framework completely fails to respect the laws of nature or enforce absolute planetary limits to prevent further ecological damage. Instead, the report asserts that boundaries are merely “limitations imposed by the present state of technology and social organization.” My critique presented in the seminar was as follows:

 “This perspective is extremely dangerous because it treats nature’s limits as flexible variables. Under this logic, the modern solution to an environmental crisis is never to halt exploitation, but rather to hide it by upgrading technology to extract resources more efficiently.

Consequently, this entire concept remains fundamentally anthropocentric and approaches ecological survival from a purely managerial point of view. Its ultimate goal is simply to find ways to ‘absorb the effects of human activities,’ completely disregarding the intrinsic value and balance of the biosphere and its fragile ecosystems.”

That is why the whole discourse on sustainable development is often looked upon as an ingenious attempt to control the damages created by unbridled economic growth and to justify the continuance of the existing pattern of development with cosmetic changes. However, this report was a milestone in the development discourse because it raised doubts about the continuance of the existing pattern of development and underscored the need for economic and environmental reforms.


5. Major Global Summits and Frameworks (1992–2012)

The Earth Summit (1992): Establishing the Global Blueprint

Twenty years after the first United Nations Conference on the Human Environment, the UN—through its historic Earth Summit in 1992—sought to help governments rethink their policies on economic development and find ways to halt the destruction of irreplaceable natural resources and the pollution of the planet. The United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), informally known as the Earth Summit, which took place in Rio de Janeiro in June 1992, was a landmark event bringing together Heads of State and Chiefs of Government, officials of international organizations, and representatives of non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and others. Two multilateral treaties—namely, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the Convention on Biological Diversity—were opened for signature. The outcome of the Summit was the adoption of Agenda 21, which provides a wide-ranging blueprint for action to achieve sustainable development worldwide.

(Connection to our upcoming COP-31 dialogue): The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) is an international treaty adopted in 1992 that aims to stabilize greenhouse gas concentrations to prevent "dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system." It established a basic framework for global climate action, and later agreements—such as the Kyoto Protocol (2005) and the Paris Agreement (2016)—have built upon it by setting specific, binding commitments for countries to reduce emissions and limit global temperature rise. COP 31 ( 31 st Conference of Parties ) now  taking place at the Antalya Expo Center in Antalya, Türkiye, from   November 9 to November 20, 2026 is the latest session of the supreme decision making body of UNFCC .  

The ICPD Programme of Action (1994) and the Beijing Platform for Action (1995)

As the concept of sustainability continued to evolve, global summits also integrated human rights and gender equity as foundational pillars of sustainable development:

  • The ICPD Programme of Action (1994): Adopted at the International Conference on Population and Development (ICPD) held in Cairo, Egypt, from 5 to 13 September 1994, this document laid out a far-sighted plan for advancing human well-being that places the human rights of individuals, rather than numerical population targets, at the centre of the global development agenda.
  • The Beijing Platform for Action (1995): Resulting from the Fourth World Conference on Women held in Beijing from 4 to 15 September 1995, the Beijing Declaration explicitly connected gender justice to our core theme of balancing three distinct pillars:

“We are deeply convinced that economic development, social development and environmental protection are interdependent and mutually reinforcing components of sustainable development, which is the framework for our efforts to achieve a higher quality of life for all people. Equitable social development that recognizes empowering the poor, particularly women living in poverty, to utilize environmental resources sustainably is a necessary foundation for sustainable development. We also recognize that broad-based and sustained economic growth in the context of sustainable development is necessary to sustain social development and social justice.”

The World Summit on Sustainable Development (2002)

The World Summit on Sustainable Development, held in Johannesburg, South Africa, in 2002 (also known as Rio+10), reaffirmed its commitment to sustainable development to ensure an equilibrium between nature’s resources and human needs. Directly echoing the Club of Rome’s concept of limits, it asserted that development which comes at the cost of natural resources should not exceed the carrying capacity of the planet. The challenge before the Summit was how to reconcile development and economic growth with environmental sustainability. The Johannesburg Declaration on Sustainable Development clearly stated:

“We assume a collective responsibility to advance and strengthen the interdependent and mutually reinforcing pillars of sustainable development - economic development, social development and environmental protection - at the local, national, regional and global levels.”

Rio+20 (2012)

Coinciding with the twentieth anniversary of the Earth Summit, the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development—popularly known as Rio+20—was held in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, in June 2012. The objective of the Conference was to secure renewed political commitment for sustainable development, assess the progress and gaps in the implementation of the outcomes of the major summits on sustainable development, and address new and emerging challenges. It decided to launch a process to develop a set of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) that would build upon the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) and converge with the post-2015 development agenda. The Conference also adopted groundbreaking guidelines on green economy policies.

6. Sustainable Development Goals: The 2030 Agenda

Finally, to chalk out the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), on the occasion of the 70th anniversary of the United Nations, a summit of world leaders was held in New York in September 2015. It adopted the 17 Sustainable Development Goals endorsed by all 193 Member States of the UN. The UN Secretary-General’s remarks at the Summit for the adoption of the development agenda clearly indicated the new global goals of the UN and the paradigm shift in its approach to peace and development. Ban Ki-moon said:

“We have reached a defining moment in human history. The people of the world have asked us to shine a light on a future of promise and opportunity. Member States have responded with the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. ... It is a universal, integrated and transformative vision for a better world. It is an agenda for people, to end poverty in all its forms. An agenda for the planet, our common home. An agenda for shared prosperity, peace and partnership. It conveys the urgency of climate action. It is rooted in gender equality and respect for the rights of all. Above all, it pledges to leave no one behind.”

The resolution named “Transforming Our World: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development,” adopted on September 25, 2015, placed before all countries of the world a plan to achieve these goals over a period of 15 years. It aims to end poverty and hunger, protect the ecosystem, and ensure peace and prosperity for future generations. The 17 Sustainable Development Goals of the United Nations are the following:

  1. End poverty in all its forms everywhere
  2. End hunger, achieve food security and improved nutrition and promote sustainable agriculture
  3. Ensure healthy lives and promote well-being for all at all ages
  4. Ensure inclusive and equitable quality education and promote lifelong learning opportunities for all
  5. Achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls
  6. Ensure availability and sustainable management of water and sanitation for all
  7. Ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and modern energy for all
  8. Promote sustained, inclusive and sustainable economic growth, full and productive employment and decent work for all
  9. Build resilient infrastructure, promote inclusive and sustainable industrialization and foster innovation
  10. Reduce inequality within and among countries
  11. Make cities and human settlements inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable
  12. Ensure sustainable consumption and production patterns
  13. Take urgent action to combat climate change and its impacts
  14. Conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and marine resources for sustainable development
  15. Protect, restore and promote sustainable use of terrestrial ecosystems, sustainably manage forests, combat desertification, and halt and reverse land degradation and halt biodiversity loss
  16. Promote peaceful and inclusive societies for sustainable development, provide access to justice for all and build effective, accountable and inclusive institutions at all levels
  17. Strengthen the means of implementation and revitalize the Global Partnership for Sustainable Development

Further, these Sustainable Development Goals served as the theme for the International Day of Peace 2016: “The Sustainable Development Goals: Building Blocks for Peace.” The International Day of Peace in 2016 served as a reminder to humanity about the significance and role of sustainable development in achieving everlasting peace.

Where We Stand :2030 Agenda

With just four years left to achieve the SDG targets, there is a clear gap between ambition and reality on the ground. This is clearly evident from Sustainable Development Goals Report 2026

Li Junhua, Under-Secretary-General for Economic and Social Affairs, in his introduction to The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2026, wrote on where we stand regarding the 2030 Agenda:

“Of the 139 targets for which we can compute reliable historical trends, only 36 per cent are on track or making moderate progress. Nearly half (49 per cent) are moving too slowly, and 15 per cent have slipped below their 2015 baselines. The world is far from eradicating its most pressing challenges. One in 10 people still lives in extreme poverty. Food insecurity remains well above 2015 levels, affecting 2.3 billion people. About 2.1 billion people (roughly one in four people) lack access to safely managed drinking water services. More than 150 million children are stunted. Maternal mortality remains nearly three times the global target, and everyday discrimination – still felt by one in five people worldwide – continues to limit human potential. These shortfalls are compounded by intersecting planetary and humanmade crises. In 2025, global temperatures reached 1.43°C above preindustrial levels, and atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) reached its highest concentration in 2 million years. Violent conflict surged to its highest levels in decades, reversing years of development in mere months, forcibly displacing 118 million people.

Meanwhile, official development assistance collapsed by a record 23 per cent in 2025, eroding the financial foundations that the poorest countries rely upon. As the annual SDG financing gap in developing countries hovers around $4 trillion, global military spending climbs to record highs. Because these crises are linked, they demand integrated solutions.”

  Conclusion:

These findings from The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2026 reveal the limitations of existing notions of sustainability. Some goals are even contradictory to the achievement of others. The basic issue is that we are trying to solve crises within the same framework of unbridled economic growth, which goes hand in hand with militarism, militarisation, profiteering, and exploitation. If we do not tread a new path—one which demands a complete restructuring of our lives, goals, and missions—our targets will remain out of reach.

In our previous IFPNP session, your own breakout groups pinpointed the real root of this failure while discussing need versus greed. You rightly observed that while growth is merely quantitative, true development is qualitative and holistic— and it should be grounded in the philosophy of Sarvodaya (the welfare of all) and starting with Antyodaya (uplifting the last person). You also raised the challenge of knowing exactly "how much is enough"—recognizing where legitimate need ends and destructive greed begins, despite the fact of how subjective our wants are.

Truly sustainable development demands an altogether different approach, rooted in the alternative approaches to development we discussed in the last session—many of which carry a deep Gandhian imprint and principles. By embracing the path of Ahimsa (nonviolence toward humanity and nature), the ideal of Aparigraha (non-possession), voluntary simplicity, and Trusteeship—and the Gandhian dictum that the Earth provides enough for every person's need, but not every person's greed—we can move beyond the cosmetic reforms suggested by advocates of existing patterns toward a genuinely balanced and peaceful future.


Group Feedback

Facilitator:

I have been listening carefully to everything shared about sustainable development and the summary of our current global situation. We are already at 1.43 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels, nearly surpassing the 1.5-degree goal of the Paris Agreement—a threshold we will almost certainly cross, if we have not already. The crisis is truly upon us.
As mentioned earlier, one in ten people worldwide—nearly one billion individuals—still live in extreme poverty. While there are many challenges to consider, we must also look at our global priorities. Currently, the world spends nearly 2.9 trillion dollars on the military, with the United States alone spending one trillion dollars this year.
This raises an urgent question of priorities. We are in a critical moment where we desperately need resources to address climate change and mass extinction, yet we continue to devote vast sums to military defense. In doing so, are we inadvertently fueling greater poverty and ecological collapse?
This brings us back to a fundamental question: What is self-defense? Does true self-defense require an unlimited blank check for the military, or does it also mean defending healthcare, education, and basic human needs?
In the context of sustainable economic development and the 17 goals of the UN Agenda—with only four years left to achieve them, and our current progress falling short—we must ask ourselves if we are being controlled by a purely material, military-focused definition of security.
So, I leave you with this single, vital question for our breakout session: How should we define security today, and how should that definition be reflected in our national budgets? If all of you agree, let us go ahead with the formation of groups.
Group 1
We discussed the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in our group. One member raised the idea of what exactly counts as development. The concept of development is often explained from a particular point of view, so what counts as development for countries in the Middle East is different from the Western conceptualization of development. Therefore, there needs to be a critical perspective on sustainable development that questions the very idea of development itself.
Another member emphasized Goals 16 and 17, which pertain to peace and justice, noting that all the Sustainable Development Goals are interconnected.
Our discussion also pertained to the perpetuation of colonialism. When development began, countries of the Global North took advantage of fast-paced growth and environmental resources. Now, when it comes to the Global South, we are expected to balance things. Unless there is some sort of reparation or balancing mechanism from the Global North—those who utilized environmental bounties earlier—there cannot be real justice. Overall, our group took a more critical note on the concept.
Group 2
We discussed the need for increasing funding for education and promoting self-sustainability in areas like farming, similar to what Bhutan is doing by funding conservation and development through a Sustainable Development Fee on tourism. We also focused on sovereign autonomy—allowing nations to rule themselves—referencing an example from Nigeria where foreign interest in gold created internal problems.
Additionally, there is deep concern about climate change and natural disasters affecting human security. We discussed Indira Gandhi's famous response when asked about India's environmental challenges: "Poverty and need are the greatest polluters." This highlights the need to address income inequality and reduce poverty. Finally, we discussed a constructive programme: there is a need for peace education in order to instill nonviolence in people's hearts, so that nobody will join the military, and there will be no need for it.
Group 3
We discussed security and the purpose of development. Is there really a need for security-driven development? While the SDGs cover a wide area—from education and poverty to environmental security, peace, and justice—they do not explicitly cover security from a peace-building point of view. So, we focused our discussion primarily on redefining the purpose of security.
Group 4
We explored the very idea of what security is. Different countries are building up their militaries and stockpiling nuclear bombs. Just one bomb can destroy the whole world, so why does every country feel the need to have hundreds of them? That is not going to bring true security.
As one of our members put it very nicely, true security is having a just society, fairness, respect, and equality. Those are the things that really bring security to a person. We discussed how this closely relates to Maslow's hierarchy of needs, where self-actualization sits at the very top, encompassing fairness and respect. Together, Mahatma Gandhi's concept of Sarvodaya (universal uplift) and Maslow's self-actualization offer a true definition of security.
Group 5
In our group, we contrasted military security with real human security, concluding that investing heavily in the military is not a sustainable path forward. We discussed how, in the context of India, around 4.1% of GDP is invested in education (with the central government's direct budget share under 3%), compared to a hefty amount going to the military. My colleagues also emphasized that healthcare, education, and women's safety must be prioritized. Another member mentioned that there are currently around 65 active armed conflicts going on in the world, and developing nations—despite being deprived of basic needs—still end up diverting resources toward conflict instead of meeting internal needs.
We also briefly discussed the environment. We emphasized that governments need to allocate more funding toward environmental protection and address global carbon emissions. Finally, a colleague from The Gambia shared that while their country allocates a very small budget to the military and keeps public healthcare fees among the lowest in Africa, the quality of healthcare still struggles due to a lack of resources.
Closing Remarks
Friends, thank you so much for your wonderful discussions and summaries. I just shared a diagrammatic representation showing the overall progress across 139 targets using the 2026 trend data: when you look at it, only about 15% are strictly on track, which is shown in green. On the other hand, we see in red that regression is also at 15%. That is the ground reality. In the coming days, we will be discussing further themes focusing on fossil fuels and COP, including another session examining COP31 in Türkiye from a critical lens.


Saturday, November 7, 2026

Understanding the Concept of Development : Dr. Siby Kollappallil Joseph

 


Understanding the Concept of Development

Dr. Siby Kollappallil Joseph

                   Director, International  Online Fellowship Program on Nonviolence and Peace (IFPNP)

                              Sevagram Ashram Pratishthan, Wardha, Maharashtra, India



Part I: The Historical Evolution of Mainstream Development

1. Introduction

One of the modules of the International Fellowship Program on Nonviolence and Peace (IFPNP) is "Global Sustainability Challenges and Responses: An Analysis." Understanding the concept of development is imperative for analysing global sustainability challenges and their responses. The term development is widely used across governments, academia, NGOs, UN agencies, and grassroots movements. It carries multidisciplinary connotations and holds different meanings in fields ranging from management to health sciences. Due to my background in economics and the fact that my doctoral studies focused on the broad gamut of development studies, my attempt will be to explore the concept of development from mainstream economic perspectives.

Classical Foundations (18th Century – Mid-20th Century)

Although the specific term "development economics" originated and became popular in the mid-20th century, the core subject of economic development was a primary concern for economists starting with Adam Smith, who is widely considered the Father of Modern Economics. Adam Smith was an 18th-century Scottish economist and philosopher who popularized the economic policy of a laissez-faire economy. His most famous 1776 book, The Wealth of Nations (An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations), discusses—according to Nobel laureate economist Amartya Sen—the basic issues of development economics. As Amartya Sen wrote:

“‘An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations’ was, in fact, also an inquiry into the basic issues of development economics. … Interest in development problems has, traditionally, provided one of the deepest motivations for the pursuit of economics in general, and this broad basis of development economics has to be borne in mind when investigating the details of the concept of development. … It is not hard to see why the concept of development is so essential to economics in general. … The enhancement of living conditions must clearly be an essential—if not the essential—object of the entire economic exercise, and that enhancement is an integral part of the concept of development.”
— Amartya Sen, "The Concept of Development," Chapter 1 in Handbook of Development Economics, Vol. 1, edited by Hollis Chenery and T. N. Srinivasan (Netherlands: Elsevier, 1988).

Even though the concept entered mainstream discourse in the mid-20th century, we are still grappling in the dark over what the term exactly means. While preparing for this session, I had a brief discussion with someone who has been working in the development sector for a long time. I asked him what keywords come to mind when we talk about the concept of development, and he shared the following:

  1. Development
  2. Progress
  3. Growth
  4. Sustainability
  5. Evolution
  6. Balancing

While analysing the concept of development, these keywords may provide valuable insights, as they depict the shifting priorities of development over time and in accordance with the realities of each particular period. Although I am familiar with all of these terms, the significance of the word evolution was not entirely clear to me at first. He explained: "Every process has a natural ability to adjust itself and transform into a new form. Every living system has an inner adaptive capacity so that it can absorb shocks, learn from experience, and adjust itself."

This insight sparked new thoughts on how to look at development. That is the reason I am viewing the concept of development as an evolutionary process—one that responds to the challenges of the time and the realization of the inadequacies of existing notions. Just like a living system, development thinking evolves in response to crises and shortcomings, giving rise to various frameworks. We will trace this thread of evolution and orientation through different stages in chronological order.

2. Origins of Modern Development Economics

Post-WWII Context and the Birth of the Discipline

Looking at the historical context of its origin, modern development economics emerged primarily out of the large-scale devastation of World War II. Industrial facilities across Europe were heavily destroyed by aerial bombardment, and severe damage to transportation infrastructure—such as railways, bridges, and docks—disrupted trade flows and caused widespread economic isolation. In contrast, the infrastructure of two major nations, the United States and Canada, remained unaffected, resulting in a rapid economic boom in North America.

In the immediate aftermath of the war, there was an urgent need for theories and policies to rebuild war-torn Europe and Japan. Key international financial institutions were established—most notably the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank (created at the 1944 Bretton Woods Conference)—to promote global economic stability and reconstruction. Against this backdrop, the post-war period witnessed the emergence of development economics as an independent academic discipline, with the United States serving as the prime mover in the post-war economic revival.

3.Orientations in Different Stages

1940s–1960s: Development as Growth

Let us look at the orientations in the process of evolution of the concept of development.

In mainstream economic thought, economic growth is a narrower, strictly quantitative concept, whereas economic development is a broader, multidimensional concept encompassing qualitative improvements in a society's overall well-being:

  • Economic Growth: Quantifies the increase in a nation's production of goods and services, typically measured by Gross Domestic Product (GDP) or per capita income.
  • Economic Development: Refers to the structural transformation of an economy from a low-income, agrarian system to a modern, industrialized, and service-oriented one, accompanied by improvements in living standards, education, healthcare, and human well-being.
  • Progress: While often used synonymously with development, progress generally implies forward movement toward a more advanced state, historically linked to technological innovation, increased productivity, and improved living standards.

What is significant about the 1940s–1960s is that economic development and economic growth became virtually synonymous. The primary policy concern was the rapid expansion of wealth in terms of GDP and per capita income, and the pursuit of growth became the ruling ideology dominating the global economy. Although mainstream economists long viewed continuous growth as the primary engine for poverty reduction, heavy reliance on capital-intensive and automated industries has increasingly resulted in "jobless growth"—a phenomenon that has reached new heights over the course of time.

European Recovery Programme (ERP)

One of the major initiatives to rebuild European economies after the Second World War was the European Recovery Programme (ERP), popularly known as the Marshall Plan (1948–1951). This was named after United States Secretary of State George C. Marshall, who gave an outline of the plan in a speech delivered at Harvard University on June 5, 1947. This American initiative, enacted in 1948, aimed to provide foreign aid to Western Europe.

Harry Truman's Address and  Four-Point Foreign Policy Goals:

Harry Truman—re-elected to the office of President of the United States for a second term—outlined a strategy for global recovery and peace in his inaugural address delivered on January 20, 1949. He argued that the resources of the world should be pooled to achieve "peace, plenty, and freedom".

Four-Point Foreign Policy Goals

  • Greater production is the key to prosperity and peace. Furthermore, the key to greater production is a wider and more vigorous application of modern scientific and technical knowledge.
  • Only by helping the least fortunate of its members to help themselves can the human family achieve the decent, satisfying life that is the right of all people.
  • Democracy alone can supply the vitalizing force to stir the peoples of the world into triumphant action—not only against their human oppressors, but also against their ancient enemies: hunger, misery, and despair.
  • On the basis of these four major courses of action, we hope to help create the conditions that will lead eventually to personal freedom and happiness for all mankind.

The Golden Age of Capitalism

A major chunk of the European Recovery Programme (ERP) aid was used by European nations to buy manufactured goods and raw materials from the United States and Canada. As a result, the United States economy witnessed a phenomenal surge in economic growth. This post-war economic boom, widely described as the Golden Age of Capitalism, spanned from the end of the Second World War in 1945 to the early 1970s.

It was a period of unprecedented economic prosperity characterized by high, sustained levels of productivity and industrial growth, particularly in many countries that had been badly devastated by the war. However, while this era brought high employment rates and rising consumerism, it also accelerated the polarization of society, deepening the divide between the rich and the poor, and between capitalists and labourers.

W.W. Rostow: The Five Stages of Economic Growth

In 1960, the American economist and government official Walt Whitman Rostow enunciated his influential model, the Stages of Economic Growth. He presented five distinct steps through which all countries must pass to achieve fully developed status:

  1. The Traditional Society: An agrarian, labour-intensive economy with low levels of trading and limited technology.
  2. Preconditions for Take-off: The development of manufacturing, industrial growth, and the initiation of an international trade outlook.
  3. The Take-off: A period of intensive industrialization where economic growth becomes self-sustaining.
  4. The Drive to Maturity: A stage marked by a rising standard of living, technological advancement, economic diversification, and reduced dependence on imports.
  5. The Age of High Mass Consumption: A capitalist system characterized by high production levels, widespread consumerism, and substantial discretionary income.

This "Non-Communist Manifesto" of Rostow became the ruling paradigm of development across both developed and developing nations, including India. It aimed to transform traditional agrarian societies into advanced consumer economies through the exponential growth of Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and per capita income.

Ultimately, this structural pattern resulted in a stark North-South divide, wherein the developed nations of the Global North exploited a lion's share of the world’s resources and pocketed the major chunk of development benefits. Even within developing countries like India, this model led to the concentration of wealth in the hands of a few, unbridled exploitation of renewable and non-renewable resources, widespread social disparity, environmental degradation, and the escalation of violent movements rooted in poverty and unemployment.

The United States under the Marshall Plan, deployed over $13 billion between 1948 and 1952 to revive Western Europe. The immediate success of the Marshall Plan prompted economists in the 1950s and 1960s to shift their attention toward the struggling economies of Africa, Asia, and Latin America. However, researchers quickly realized that the deep structural challenges faced by historically impoverished countries were fundamentally different from those of post-war Europe, thereby requiring unique, tailored policies rather than a copy-paste approach.

4.1970s: Development as Basic Needs

By the late 1960s and early 1970s, it became glaringly evident that the "trickle-down" theory—the assumption that aggregate economic growth would naturally filter down to the poorest sectors—had failed. In response to this crisis, the International Labour Organization (ILO) Director-General David Morse launched the World Employment Programme at the 1969 International Labour Conference.

Later, the Programme of Action adopted at the 1976 ILO World Employment Conference highlighted employment as the primary vehicle for generating output and income, establishing the foundational "basic-needs" strategy. During this same decade, the World Bank, under the leadership of President Robert McNamara, shifted its institutional focus to emphasize that development must prioritize meeting core human needs: food, shelter, healthcare, education, and employment.

Despite its progressive goals, the fatal flaw of the basic-needs era was that it treated impoverished populations merely as passive beneficiaries rather than active partners in their own advancement. This top-down paternalism ultimately reinforced the structural dependency between the Global North and the Global South.

5.1980s–90s: Development as Freedom

During this period, we see a profound shift in emphasis due to the contributions of economists like Amartya Sen. Development began to be viewed through the dimension of human freedom, linking it directly to the expansion of people's capabilities—what they can be and what they can do. This framework expands the definition of development beyond material wealth to include human freedoms, healthcare, education, and overall well-being.

Amartya Sen viewed development as a process of expanding human freedom, which necessitates removing the sources of "unfreedom." He argued that freedom is both the primary means and the ultimate end of development. True development involves removing constraints such as poverty and lack of opportunity—specifically the lack of economic facilities, social opportunities, political freedom, transparency, and protective security. As a result, the focus of development shifted from being economy-centric to human-centric.

The UNDP Human Development Report adopted this approach and introduced the Human Development Index (HDI), measuring life expectancy, education, and income. For the first time, a country could be recognized as rich in GDP yet poor in human development.

The HDI was developed by Mahbub ul Haq, an economist at the World Bank in the 1970s who later served as Pakistan's Minister of Finance, and was further fine-tuned with inputs from Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum. As the founder of the Human Development Report, Haq explained the core purpose of development in the following words:

“The basic purpose of development is to enlarge people’s choices. In principle, these choices can be infinite and can change over time. People often value achievements that do not show up at all, or not immediately, in income or growth figures: greater access to knowledge, better nutrition and health services, more secure livelihoods, security against crime and physical violence, satisfying leisure hours, political and cultural freedoms and sense of participation in community activities. The objective of development is to create an enabling environment for people to enjoy long, healthy and creative lives.”

This index is considered a major advancement over the narrow, growth-centred notion of development. In 1990, Haq published the first Human Development Report, which was commissioned by the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP). The Human Development Index is a summary measure of average achievement in three key dimensions of human development: a long and healthy life, being knowledgeable, and having a decent standard of living.

6. Late 1980s–2015: Development as Sustainability

The publication of the UN’s Brundtland Report (Our Common Future) in 1987 brought the concept of sustainable development into mainstream discourses. The UN followed it through landmark summits including Rio 1992, the 1995 World Summit for Social Development, and Rio+20 in 2012. This culminated on September 25, 2015, when all 193 UN Member States adopted "Transforming Our World: the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development," committing to 17 Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) over a span of 15 years. We will be devoting a separate session to sustainable development. Here it is described only to give the orientation of the concept of development during this period.


 

Part II

Evolution of Alternative Concepts of Development


Alternative development thinking evolved from time to time within and outside mainstream economics in response to crises and shortcomings, giving way to new ideas. I think these ideas are significant from the point of view of two key words which I brought into notice: sustainability and balancing. Let us examine some of the key alternatives in the field of development to gain knowledge of these frameworks and their significance.

7.Gross National Happiness

As early as 1972, the Fourth King of Bhutan, Jigme Singye Wangchuck, stated that Gross National Happiness is more important than Gross National Product. It later became part and parcel of Bhutan’s policy of development. It comprises an index which is used to measure the collective happiness and well-being of a population. Gross National Happiness is instituted as the goal of the government of Bhutan in the Constitution enacted on 18 July 2008.  Article 9 ‘Principles of State Policy’ reads as follows. “The State shall strive to promote those conditions that will enable the pursuit of Gross National Happiness.” The concept of GNH has four pillars: good governance, sustainable socio-economic development, cultural preservation, and environmental conservation. Later the four pillars have been further classified into nine domains to depict GNH values. The nine domains are: psychological wellbeing, health, education, time use, cultural diversity and resilience, good governance, community vitality, ecological diversity and resilience, and living standards. Thirty-three indicators categorized under nine domains of GNH Index. In 2011, The United Nations General Assembly passed a Resolution "Happiness: towards a holistic approach to development" urging member nations to follow the example of Bhutan and measure happiness and well-being and calling happiness a "fundamental human goal”. Many countries of the world accepted it as a policy of their respective governments.

8. Institutional Economics (1980s–1990s)

The role of the state is a crucial determinant of the entire development process. During the Thatcherite era of the 1980s, the role of the state in development was downgraded and sidelined. Later, in the 1990s, international agencies such as the World Bank gave renewed recognition to the vital role of the state and its institutions. This shift was partly driven by the rise of New Institutional Economics, pioneered and propounded by Nobel laureate Douglass North. In his seminal 1993 essay, "The New Institutional Economics and Development," North skillfully summarized the essential characteristics of institutional economics, how it differs from neoclassical theory, and how it applies to the challenges of development. As he wrote:

“It is polities that shape economic performance because they define and enforce the economic rules of the game. Therefore, the heart of development policy must be the creation of polities that will create and enforce efficient property rights.”

 

9. Measuring Well-Being Beyond GDP: The Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission (2008–2009)

By the turn of the century, the conventional approach to development was increasingly questioned by leaders and economists across many countries, leading to the emergence of new ways of development thinking and practice. These alternative approaches have been gaining ground globally, enriching the very idea of development. This shift in thinking is clearly evident in the findings of the Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission.

In February 2008, the then-President of the French Republic, Nicolas Sarkozy, dissatisfied with existing statistical measures of the economy and society, approached Joseph Stiglitz (Columbia University, Chair of the Commission), Amartya Sen (Harvard University, Chair Adviser), and Jean-Paul Fitoussi (French economist, Coordinator) to establish a commission to identify the limits of GDP as an indicator of economic performance and social progress. This body became formally known as the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress (CMEPSP), or the Stiglitz-Sen-Fitoussi Commission.

In its landmark 2009 report, the Commission observed:

“The time is ripe for our measurement system to shift emphasis from measuring economic production to measuring people’s well-being. And measures of well-being should be put in a context of sustainability... Emphasizing well-being is important because there appears to be an increasing gap between the information contained in aggregate GDP data and what counts for common people’s well-being.”
— J. Stiglitz, A. Sen, and J.-P. Fitoussi, Report by the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress (2009).

 

10. Inclusive Growth & The Inclusive Development Index (2015–2017)

In the context of growing disparity and division between the countries of the Global North and Global South, the idea of inclusive growth became a prominent concept in development discourse during the 2000s and 2010s. The Inclusive Development Index (IDI) is an economic index introduced by the World Economic Forum (WEF) in 2017 (following a preliminary policy framework released in 2015) as an alternative to GDP for measuring a country's economic growth and development. Through this index, a country's economic performance is evaluated on the basis of twelve indicators of economic progress alongside GDP, structured around three core pillars: growth and development; inclusion; and intergenerational equity and sustainable stewardship of natural and financial resources. It aims to inform and enable sustained, inclusive economic progress through deepened public-private cooperation—driven by thought leadership, analysis, strategic dialogue, and concrete collaboration, including accelerating social impact through corporate action.

11. Doughnut Economics (2012–2017)

The concept of Doughnut Economics was developed by British economist Kate Raworth in a 2012 Oxfam paper and later expanded in her 2017 book, Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st-Century Economist. According to Raworth, mainstream economics measures progress almost exclusively through endless GDP growth, ignoring the finite nature of Earth’s resources and the ecological consequences of human activity. To address this, she sought to create an economic model fit for the 21st century, built on the core premise that "Humanity’s 21st-century challenge is to meet the needs of all within the means of the planet."

The seven chapters in her book outline seven transformative ways to think like a 21st-century economist:

  1. Change the goal — from GDP to the Doughnut.
  2. See the big picture — from a self-contained market to an embedded economy.
  3. Nurture human nature — from rational economic man to social, adaptable humans.
  4. Get savvy with systems — from mechanical equilibrium to dynamic complexity.
  5. Design to distribute — from "growth will even it up again" to distributive by design.
  6. Create to regenerate — from "growth will clean it up again" to regenerative by design.
  7. Be agnostic about growth — from growth-addicted to growth-agnostic.

 

12. Specific Diseconomy & Institutional Critique (1970s)

There is also a stream of scholars who envision a form of development that relies neither on the government nor on the market; instead, they argue it should be centred on the people and their own wisdom. Among them was Ivan Illich, a Croatian-Austrian philosopher, who severely criticized the institutions of contemporary Western civilization, as well as modern policies and practices in education, health, work, and the very idea of economic development. In his influential 1970s works—such as Deschooling Society (1971), Tools for Conviviality (1973), and Medical Nemesis (1975)—he coined the term “specific disutility” (or “specific diseconomy”) to measure the degree of institutional counterproductivity and inefficiency across various sectors. Illich cited examples such as the medical industry inducing illness (iatrogenesis), educational institutions contributing to the ignorance of pupils, and the judicial system perpetuating injustice. When specific diseconomy increases, it signifies that an institution or industry is progressively becoming counterproductive—defeating the very goals for which it was established. His analysis became a guiding light for later critics of colonialism and post-colonialism, as well as post-development theorists such as Arturo Escobar and Gustavo Esteva.

13. Post-Development Theory (Late 1980s–1990s)

Emerging prominently in the late 1980s and 1990s, post-development theory is essentially an anti-development critique based on the premise that the entire concept and practice of conventional "development" is a reflection of Western-Northern hegemony over the rest of the world. Post-development theorists like Arturo Escobar (notably in his 1995 book Encountering Development) and Gustavo Esteva have challenged the very goal and purpose of development, arguing that it has always been unjust, never worked, and was an utter failure. Wolfgang Sachs, a leading figure of the post-development school, wrote in his introduction to the 1992 edited volume The Development Dictionary: A Guide to Knowledge as Power:

“The idea of development stands like a ruin in the intellectual landscape. Delusion and disappointment, failures and crimes, have been the steady companions of development and they tell a common story: it did not work.”

He further declared: “It is time to dismantle this mental structure.”

 14. The Earth-Centric Approach to Development (1970s–Present)

The earth-centric approach to development gained momentum from the 1970s onward in response to the severe environmental damage caused by industrial development, introducing several new concepts into development discourse. One prominent example is the Gaia hypothesis, formulated by chemist James Lovelock and co-developed with microbiologist Lynn Margulis in the 1970s, which places Mother Earth and ecological sustainability at the centre of development concerns. Etymologically, the word Gaia is derived from the Greek Gaîa—the primordial Earth goddess in Greek mythology—and literally means "Earth." The hypothesis proposes that the biotic (living) and abiotic (non-living) components of Earth function as a single, self-regulating organism that maintains conditions conducive to life. Alongside the Gaia concept, ideas such as deep ecology (coined by Arne Næss in 1973) and ecofeminism (introduced by Françoise d'Eaubonne in 1974) have also gained prominence in development debates. Notably, many of these contemporary alternative frameworks carry a deep imprint of Gandhian ideas and ideals.


Question & Answer

Observation/Question: Thank you so much for the wonderful session. We learned many things, and we took notes. Your interpretation of the six keywords was very new and novel. Through that framework, you discussed how the concept of development evolved. I'm looking at it from Gandhi's point of view—a Gandhian state of development, or a mode of development.

Development versus growth is a constant debate which has been ongoing for a very long time, especially within development economics. When we think from a Gandhian point of view, there is a similarity. I just want to get your opinion about greed versus need. Can we put it in a framework where development and growth can be co-terminated—defining development as  need, and growth as greed? I do not know, am I making sense with that question or my observation?

Speaker: Thank you, definitely yes. This question can be discussed in the group: how you look upon development, and whether you can think of development as a need-based strategy and growth as a greed-based strategy. This point can be debated. It may not be possible for me to discuss it here in detail.

J.C. Kumarappa was a premier interpreter of Gandhian economics. One of his most well-known writings is Economy of Permanence. The Gandhian economy visualized by Kumarappa calls for a simple life based on the fulfilment of basic needs and necessities. It opposes an artificial economy driven by greed, which demands a multiplicity of wants, distinguishing cleanly between a "simple life" and a "complex life."

Those who are interested in the Gandhian perspective may refer to my article, "United Nations Sustainable Development Goals and Kumarappa's Economy of Permanence." It originally appeared in Gandhi Marg, Volume number 39, January-March 2018. It was reproduced on mkgandhi.org. One of the participants already shared the link: mkgandhi.org which you may refer to. Remember that it was written in 2018, not 2026. If I write it in 2026, it may be different.

Friends, shall we go for the group discussion? Are you comfortable with the topic: development versus growth? Or, put differently, need versus greed. In that case, please go ahead with the group formation and breakout rooms.


Feedback from Group Discussions

Moderator: I think most of them have joined back. There was an error in editing the time, and most of you got enough time to discuss the most difficult topic of today's breakout rooms. We have only five minutes left, so I request each of the five groups to take one minute to share their thoughts. Thank you. Group number one.

Group One: We spoke at first mostly about development, growth, greed, and need. We tried to brainstorm on that, but due to lack of time, we could not do much.Regarding development versus growth, what we spoke about is that growth is mostly about quantity. It can be at an individual, family, social, or national level—concerning more GDP and more production. But when we talk about development, it goes beyond the numbers. It is not just about quantity. We are talking about the quality behind those numbers. What is being produced? How is it impacting people, especially those who are standing at the very end of the queue? We can connect this to the Gandhian concepts of Sarvodaya and Antyodaya.

If real development happens as a holistic phenomenon affecting everything from the individual up to the national level, it can lead to peace. That was also our connection to the core theme of our program. Along with that, we spoke about development versus growth using a small case study of education from the Gandhian concept, especially regarding Nai Talim. Here, we are not just collecting degrees or certificates; we are learning life skills. So, at a personal educational level, we are talking about development.

We also had a brief discussion about how growth can be equated to greed. However, a contradictory view also emerged: up to a certain point, growth is a need; only beyond that point does it become greed. Knowing how much is sufficient and how much is enough is crucial. That is a vital skill, both at a personal level and on a larger scale. We should know how much is sufficient. A growth economy driven by greed can lead to inequality, whereas holistic development leads to overall well-being.

Group Two: We talked about development and growth. Growth is related to quantity and an increase in production, while development focuses on the people and their quality of life. Nowadays, there is a heavily capitalistic approach towards development, but development should be inclusive. It should not cause harm to the climate; it should happen in a sustainable way.We spoke about Mahatma Gandhi's idea of Sarvodaya, which stands for the welfare of all, and emphasized that the development of the last person in society is incredibly important. We noted that in the name of development, there is a massive destruction of the environment. That goes directly against true development and should not be happening. This was the core of our discussion.

Group Three: What we did was discuss both development and growth, as well as greed versus need. The theme on which we had a very good discussion was: where does need end, and where does greed begin? That led into a discussion on the idea of nonviolence itself—whether violence and nonviolence exist on a continuous spectrum, or if they are two completely separate things. It depends on the epistemological or ontological point of view from which you view violence and nonviolence. In that same sense, we discussed whether greed and need constitute a continuum, or if they are two entirely different things.

Group Four: One of our members spoke about how development is an ongoing process, but noted that while development in India is moving forward very fast, there is still a vast difference across areas. When we visit rural areas, we find significant inequality. In a Gandhian theme, equality must be present in every field. Right now, some people are very rich and some are very poor; the gap between the rich and the poor is stark.

I think that growth and development are related, but they are not the same. Growth refers to an increase in numbers, quantity, and physical capacity. Development means overall progress, which is long-term and takes time, just like sustainability. According to Gandhism, equality must be there. If we focus only on modern development, we risk destroying our past, including our culture.

Our lifestyle is completely different now; from the way we live to the way we eat. Even our life expectancy seems to be decreasing. Our forefathers used to survive and live up to a hundred years, but nowadays, people are dying at fifty-six or sixty. Why? Because of environmental pollution caused by this type of development. We want overall development, but we are not thinking about our own health and our conditions. In a Gandhian perspective, growth and development are different, but equality must be central. In our group, we discussed this balance.

Group Five: I think the core point raised in our group was that even when we share the same goals, needs can be completely subjective. What is a need for me could be something entirely different for you. Maybe what I consider a need is seen as greed by someone else, and vice versa. This subjectivity opens up many potential problems in the world when we don't have a shared, fair understanding of needs in their most fundamental sense.


Concluding Remarks

Speaker: Thank you so much for the insights from the group discussions. I see an underlying thread that unites our vision, though the discussion took place in various groups. I don't know whether my lecture made sense or if it was too academic and complicated. Thank you all once again.

 






 


COP 31 : A Critical Examination

  About Mr Sagar Dhara Mr. Sagar Dhara is a researcher and writer, with a deep understanding of the energetics (energy flows) of human socie...